SANTA CRUZ: The fidget spinner craze has been sweeping schools. As of May 17, every one of the top 10 best-selling toys on Amazon was a form of the hand-held toy people can spin and do tricks with. Kids and parents are even making them for themselves using 3D printers and other homespun-crafting techniques.
But some teachers are banning them from classrooms. And experts challenge the idea that spinners are good for conditions like Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and anxiety. Meanwhile, the Kickstarter online fundraising campaign for the Fidget Cube – another popular fidget toy in 2017 – raised an astounding US$6.4 million (S$8.9 million) and can be seen on the desks of hipsters and techies across the globe.
My research group has taken a deep look at how people use fidget items over the last several years. What we found tells us that these items are not a fad that will soon disappear. Despite sometimes being an annoying distraction for others, fidget items can have some practical uses for adults; our inquiry into their usefulness for children is underway.
Fidgeting didn’t start with the spinner craze. If you’ve ever clicked a ballpoint pen again and again, you’ve used a fidget item. As part of our work, we’ve asked people what items they like to fidget with and how and when they use them.
One thing people often report is that fidgeting with an object in their hand helps them stay focussed when doing a time-consuming task or in sitting still and being attentive in a long meeting. Many examples people have told us about are ready-on-hand objects like paper clips, USB thumb drives, headphone earbuds and sticky tape. But people also buy specialised items like a fidget spinner or a Fidget Cube for this purpose.
Another common thread involves people using some fidget objects – like a favorite smooth stone – to calm themselves down, helping them achieve a more relaxed, contemplative, even mindful state.
FINE-TUNING FOR FOCUS
Psychology research about sensation seeking tells us that people often seek to adjust their experiences and their environments so that they provide just the right level of stimulation. Different people function well under different circumstances. Some people like total quiet to help them focus, while others are happiest working in a busy, noisy environment.
The optimal level of stimulation (or lack thereof) not only varies among people but can even change for one person throughout the day depending upon what he or she is trying to do. So people fine-tune their environments to get things just right: For example, putting on headphones in a noisy office environment to substitute with less distracting noise.
A person who can’t get up and walk around, or go have a nice cup of tea to calm down, may find it helpful to use a fidget item to get in the right frame of mind to stay focussed and calm while staying put.
WHAT RESEARCHERS SAY
Our results align with anecdotal accounts about fidget toys helping children with attention or anxiety issues to stay focused and calm in the classroom. In fact, fidget toys have been available for kids for quite some time.
There hasn’t yet been a definitive study of the impact of these toys in the research world. In one preliminary study looking at stress ball use, eleven year olds who used these fidget toys during instruction independently reported that their “attitude, attention, writing abilities and peer interaction improved”.
The closest significant research is University of California Davis behavioural science professor Julie Schweitzer’s study of letting children with ADHD fidget – wriggling, bouncing or otherwise moving gently in place – while they worked on a lab-based concentration task called the “flanker paradigm.” She found that more overall movement (measured using an accelerometer on the ankle) in children with ADHD helped them perform this cognitively demanding task.
Of course, it’s a big step from that finding to a claim that fidgeting with small objects in one's hand can work, too. However, therapists tend to focus more on results than theoretical findings. They use what gets results and throw out what doesn’t, so practical experience suggests these toys may help kids.
And yet, schools are banning the spinners and teachers are taking them away. The reason is that not all fidget items are created equal.
The items that therapists recommend are primarily tactile – a user holds it in a hand and can manipulate it without looking. But fidget spinners require hand-eye coordination.
To use a fidget spinner, a person holds the centre of the spinner with thumb and finger, and then uses the other hand (or other fingers on the same hand) to get the spinner rotating. Once it’s spinning, there are tricks to be explored, like balancing the rotating spinner on a thumb.
Balancing a moving object really requires keeping an eye on it and doing tricks is a lot of what makes the spinners fun. It’s also what draws the eyes of the user away from the teacher and likely also the eyes of nearby students. This is the bane of a teacher trying to keep a classroom focussed.
By contrast, putty, stress balls and other therapeutic fidget items don’t have this visual attention problem. They can serve the same purpose as the spinners but are more classroom-ready and less distracting. In the same way, the kickstarted Fidget Cube, too, is probably also more classroom-friendly.
Fidget items do seem to serve a valuable purpose. There’s still science to be done, but they’re not just a fad. They embody an enduring phenomenon that nearly everyone uses at some point – just watch your own behavior when doing desk work or sitting in meetings.
Katherine Isbister Is Professor of Computational Media at the University of California, Santa Cruz. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation. Read it here.