channelnewsasia.com - Vatican rejects right to die after Italian court ruling
   
 
  blogs  
 
yournews
   
   
Video Finance Lifestyle Travel Weather Discussion TV Shows
CNA Live    | About Us 
 
  Home ›
 
World News

 
 

Vatican rejects "right to die" after Italian court ruling
Posted: 15 November 2008 0024 hrs

 
 
Photos  of

   
 


ROME : The Vatican on Friday firmly condemned an Italian court decision allowing a father to remove his comatose daughter from life support, saying "the right to die does not exist."

"Life is sacred, the right to die does not exist," the Vatican's "health minister" Cardinal Javier Lozano Barragan said in an interview published by the Italian daily La Stampa.

On Thursday, Italy's highest appeal court upheld an earlier ruling that doctors could stop artificially feeding Eluana Englaro, 37, as it had been proven that the road accident victim's coma was irreversible.

"To stop giving food and drink to Eluana is tantamount to committing murder," said Barragan, who heads the Vatican's Pontifical Council for Health Pastoral Care.

"It means letting her die of hunger and thirst, condemning her to a monstrous end," he added.

Englaro has lain in a hospital in northern Lecco since January 1992, and her father Beppino Englaro has been seeking an end to her life support since 1999.

The lower court had accepted testimony that when fully conscious Eluana Englaro had stated her preference to die rather than being kept alive artificially.

Her father hailed the ruling, telling the daily La Repubblica: "I wanted justice and the judges gave it to me. They tried to put themselves in Eluana's place, (to understand) her thoughts, her strength, her freedom and her irreversible vegetative state."

Such a state "does not exist in nature, while medicine can take forced feeding and care to an extreme, even when it no longer serves any purpose," he said.

Barragan also spoke to La Repubblica, saying: "The term 'vegetative state' is appropriate for plants, not human beings."

The Roman Catholic Church had made Englaro a symbol in its campaign against mercy killings and demanded that she be kept alive.

Avvenire, the daily newspaper of the Italian Catholic Church, had accused the lower court of "necrophilia" after its ruling in July.

In 2006, the Church refused to allow a religious funeral for poet and writer Piergiorgio Welby, a muscular dystrophy sufferer.

Welby died in December 2006 after being taken off an artificial respirator.

- AFP /ls

 

 



Other world News
Huge crowds mark fall of Berlin Wall
Iraq to hold general election on January 21
Floods, landslides kill 130 in El Salvador
US Army appeals for help in Fort Hood inquiry
London Mayor Saves Filmmaker from Mugging
Obama to meet with Israel's Netanyahu on Monday
Iraq's explosives detection gadget does not work, says US general
Colombia to seek UN help as Chavez readies army for war
Honduras president, de facto leader spar over deal
Wall anniversary celebrations kick off in Berlin
Hurricane Ida floods kill 91 in El Salvador
Iraq approves 2010 election law

 

 
Affiliate Sites:
 
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with Us  |  Terms & Conditions