blogs  
 
yournews
   
 
Video Photos Finance Travel Weather Discussion TV Shows
| |
 
  Home ›
 
Reviews

 

It's a drag
By Genevieve Loh, TODAY | Posted: 25 November 2009 0817 hrs

 
 
Photos  of

   
 


RATING:

SINGAPORE : If Mel Gibson could deliver that impassioned speech as William Wallace to inspire the Scots, then Vicki Zhao can do the very same as Hua Mulan for the Chinese.

And motivate legions of soldiers she does, as Zhao stands stoically in front of what seems like a gazillion extras to deliver those legendary blazing speeches about courage, solidarity and dying for your country.

Unfortunately, it is only those speeches and the subsequent sweeping epic battle scenes that hold up in what is otherwise a snooze-fest rehash of Mulan and her battalion vice commander Wentai ("Painted Skin" co-star Chen Kun) falling in love - despite her gender-bending ways and father's prophetic advice against feelings on the battlefield.

Set against the panorama of China 450AD, this is more sappy love story than war masterpiece, thanks to director Jingle Ma's none-too-subtle handling. His overtly grandiose sweeping shots timed with perfectly cued rousing music and close-ups of tearful eyes drags the film's pacing.

While Chen is eye candy enough and looks reasonably long-suffering and impassive, Zhao uneasily slips in and out of what could have been a standout performance - if only she was more consistent.

Jackie Chan's son Jaycee somewhat brings up the rear as the supporting comic relief, but it is Russian opera/pop singer Vitas that stands out like a sore thumb.

Overall, "Mulan" is a tad too long and tedious, thanks to the over-reliance on melodrama.

But what do you expect? After all, those warriors of bygone dynasties always had predilections of being overly-dramatic.

-
TODAY/il

 


Other reviews
The Wedding Diary: A delightful union
A Dangerous Method: Unsettling and thought-provoking
Dance Dance Dragon: Starting the Year of the Dragon with a laugh
We Not Naughty: Too much baggage, not enough fun
Flying Swords of Dragon Gate: A new wu xia classic
Sherlock Holmes, A Game of Shadows: Rollicking good fun with likeable stars
Alvin and the Chipmunks, Chipwrecked: Humour strictly for the kids
Mission Impossible, Ghost Protocol: Impossible to miss
Already Famous: Lacks polish but has a lot of heart
Puss In Boots: An all-round family pleaser
Kaiji 2: Gambling thrills galore
The Adventures of Tintin, The Secret of the Unicorn: A visual adventure
In Time: Could do with a better story
Footloose: Get your groove on!
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan: Fails to move

 

 
Affiliate Sites:
 
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with Us  |  Terms & Conditions