blogs  
 
yournews
   
 
Video Photos Finance Travel Weather Discussion TV Shows
| |
 
  Home ›
 
Reviews

 

Confucius says no
By Genevieve Loh, TODAY | Posted: 17 March 2010 1351 hrs

 
 
Photos  of

   
 


RATING:

SINGAPORE : It's been reported that China apparently took "Avatar" off the screens to forcefully make way for "Confucius", the big-budget government-financed biopic about the legendary Chinese sage. That's so not the Confucius way. And neither is this dreary film.

You know Confucius. The great theorist and ideologist who lived from 551BC to 479BC; educator and thinker whose philosophy focused on personal, social and governmental morality, justice and sincerity. The film jumps right in, tracing his rise and eventual tiff with the ruling families.

Director Hu Mei, known for her historical TV dramas, never quite finds her footing here on the silver screen, as she delivers a middling, dull biographical study. Even with Chow Yun Fatt taking a break from Hollywood to do most of the film's heavy-lifting as the titular sage, the film might have worked better as a documentary than a dramatic film.

It is Confucius' teachings rather than his life-events that ultimately show his greatness, and thus the film's lack of story-push and genuine drama disappoints. Which then makes the inclusion of ancient war battle scenes and leading lady in the form of Zhou Xun as the queen of the Wei Kingdom seem more desperate than inspiring.

What we want is a deeper study of the philosopher whose thoughts revolutionised the politics of China. But all we get is a film that barely scratches the surface.

-
TODAY/ra

 


Other reviews
The Wedding Diary: A delightful union
A Dangerous Method: Unsettling and thought-provoking
Dance Dance Dragon: Starting the Year of the Dragon with a laugh
We Not Naughty: Too much baggage, not enough fun
Flying Swords of Dragon Gate: A new wu xia classic
Sherlock Holmes, A Game of Shadows: Rollicking good fun with likeable stars
Alvin and the Chipmunks, Chipwrecked: Humour strictly for the kids
Mission Impossible, Ghost Protocol: Impossible to miss
Already Famous: Lacks polish but has a lot of heart
Puss In Boots: An all-round family pleaser
Kaiji 2: Gambling thrills galore
The Adventures of Tintin, The Secret of the Unicorn: A visual adventure
In Time: Could do with a better story
Footloose: Get your groove on!
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan: Fails to move

 

 
Affiliate Sites:
 
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with Us  |  Terms & Conditions