Skip to main content




China warns it won't tolerate dissent in Hong Kong

China warns it won't tolerate dissent in Hong Kong

China's Communist Party plenum concluded a meeting with a promise to protect the stability of Hong Kong AFP/Anthony WALLACE

BEIJING: China warned on Friday (Nov 1) that it would not tolerate any challenge to Hong Kong's governing system, as it laid out plans to boost patriotism in the city and change how its leader is chosen or removed after months of anti-government protests. 

The unrest in the semi-autonomous city was an important topic at a major, four-day meeting of the Communist Party chaired by President Xi Jinping this week in Beijing, said Shen Chunyao, director of the Hong Kong, Macau and Basic Law Commission.

The central government in Beijing has so far voiced its confidence in Hong Kong chief executive Carrie Lam and the city police to put a lid on the increasingly violent protests.

But all eyes have been on whether the party leadership will assert more control over the situation if the demonstrations spin out of control.

READ: Chinese leadership says it will ensure Hong Kong's stability and prosperity

READ: China dismisses reports of replacing Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam as 'political rumour'

The former British colony has been rocked by months of protests with citizens lampooning the city's pro-Beijing leaders and erosion on basic rights.

Shen said party leaders agreed to "further improve the central government's system of governance over the region" and maintain its "long-term prosperity and stability".

China, he added, will "never tolerate any act that challenges the bottom line of 'one country, two systems', never tolerate any act that splits the country and endangers national security, and resolutely prevent and contain foreign forces' interference in Hong Kong and Macau business".

READ: Mainland Chinese in Hong Kong worry as anti-China sentiment swells

Hong Kong's chief executive is not directly elected, a source of major friction and a headache for the leaders themselves because they have no popular mandate.

Currently, the city's leader is chosen by a 1,200-strong committee that is stacked with Beijing loyalists.

Lam, who now boasts record-low approval ratings, became leader in 2017 after securing 777 votes from that committee.

Shen said the party leaders discussed ways "to improve the mechanism of appointing and removing the chief executive and key officials of the Special Administrative Region by the central government".

The legal system of the city will also be improved to "safeguard national security," he said, without providing more details.

The party elite have decided to step up patriotic education as a way to curb youth-led protests.

"We should educate Hong Kong and Macau society, especially public officials and teenagers, about the constitution ... and strengthen the national consciousness and patriotism of Hong Kong and Macau compatriots through the education of history and Chinese culture," said Shen.


Veteran lawmaker Claudia Mo said Beijing's comments about improving the way the city's leader is chosen is mere "lip service".

"Hong Kong people have been let down all too often on that issue so I think we can just ignore that 'improvement'," she told AFP.

"We're asking for one man, one vote, minus Beijing's interference."

Political analyst Willy Lam said the comments indicated Beijing was determined to exert "tighter control" over Hong Kong in the future.

"It's to make sure the next chief executive carries out Beijing's orders more effectively that Carrie Lam has done," he told AFP.

"It has nothing to do with democracy."

Shen said China's communist leaders want "patriots to form the main body" of those selected to govern both Hong Kong and Macau.

Beijing Wednesday expressed "approval and support" for the disqualification of Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong from upcoming local elections.

Wong accused the Hong Kong government of "political screening" after an election officer ruled his nomination for the November poll invalid.


Lecturer Leung Kai-chi, of the Chinese University of Hong Kong, said changes or improvements would not help unless coupled with an increase in public trust.

"Isn't the current disaster in Hong Kong the best proof?" Leung said.

"It will be self-deceiving if the improvements do not address the recognition issue but merely reiterate the qualifications of the one chosen by the authorities."

The party elite decided this week to step up patriotic education as a way to curb youth-led protests.

Hong Kong officials and teenagers should learn about the constitution, Shen said.

The party also wants to "strengthen the national consciousness and patriotism of Hong Kong and Macau compatriots through the education of history and Chinese culture," he said.

Beijing had previously tried to beef up patriotic education in 2012, resulting in a huge backlash from Hong Kong students.

"Hong Kongers will not take this issue lying down," said Mo, referring to new moves to add Communist Party propaganda to the curriculum.

Source: AFP/ga


Also worth reading