Skip to main content

Advertisement

Advertisement

Business

Oatly surge shows alternative food remains hot commodity

Oatly surge shows alternative food remains hot commodity

Oatly containers are displayed at a grocery store, Tuesday, May 18, 2021, in North Miami, Fla. (AP Photo/Marta Lavandier)

NEW YORK: This week's rousing stock market debut of dairy alternative Oatly underlines anew people's enduring appetite for vegan products. If anything, that hunger has grown during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Following a heady NASDAQ debut on Thursday and another surge in Friday's (May 21) session, the Swedish food company is now valued at about US$13 billion, a lofty level for one that took in US$421 million in revenues last year from sales of oat-based milk, ice cream and other products not made with space-age technology.

Oatly is far from alone in the emerging space.

READ: Oat milk maker Oatly raises US$200 million from Oprah, Howard Schultz, among others

READ: Almond, oat or soy? What’s the best milk alternative if you’re lactose intolerant

Earlier this month, Nestle launched a new non-dairy milk made with peas, adding to a slate of plant-based options for burgers, sausages and tuna.

At its vast chain of coffee shops, Starbucks now offers four creamers made from something other than cow's milk: soy, almonds, coconut and, since March, oats.

And in Singapore, since December consumers have the option to purchase lab-grown chicken composed from animal muscle cells.

The alternative food industry was already on the rise before the pandemic, with startups like Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods winning praise for vegan items that surprised many consumers with their likeness to meat in terms of taste, odor and texture.

In April 2019, Burger King made waves after launching the first vegan version of its popular "Whopper" sandwich. Since then, most big fast-food chains have followed suit, while producers have joined Nestle in introducing meatless supermarket products.

READ: Lab-grown chicken to be sold in Singapore after 'world's first' approval for cultured meat

READ: Lab-grown chicken dishes sold for S$23 at private members’ club 1880

During the COVID-19 pandemic, meat alternatives enjoyed a temporary surge in interest as some consumers sought healthier products. Sales of Beyond Meat products spiked initially before moderating.

The surge also came as production problems, due partly to COVID-19 outbreaks, temporarily curtailed conventional meat availability, though supplies later stabilised.

"The pandemic opened people's eyes to the risks of the meat industry, the relative fragility of its value chain," said Jan Dutkiewicz, a fellow at Concordia University and Harvard Law School who writes often on food and environmental studies.

TRANSFORMATION AHEAD?

Investor interest in alternative meat is keen in part because of the environmental costs of conventional meat production, as well as concerns about animal welfare.

Investments in alternative food tripled in 2020 to US$3.1 billion, according to the Good Food Institute, a nonprofit.

This included US$2.1 billion for plant-based meat, egg and dairy companies; $360 million for cultivated meat companies; and $590 million for fermentation companies devoted to protein alternatives.

Sales of meat alternatives jumped 45 per cent in 2020 in the United States, but still account for only 1.4 per cent of total retail meat sales, according to the Good Food Institute.

READ: Commentary: The rising tide of alternative meat is here and we are the better for it

History shows it can be difficult for food substitutes to achieve sustained success, said Nicholas Fereday, an analyst specializing in consumer foods at Rabobank.

Despite the success of products like aspartame and stevia, sugar remains the dominant coffee sweetener, he said. And for now, nobody has been able to simulate popular items like roast beef or grilled pork with a vegan option.

"Environmental and animal welfare concerns will trigger interest among people who are looking for brands that align with their values and encourage the initial purchase," Fereday said, but they will only keep buying if they like the product.

Dutkiewicz notes that the conventional meat sector operates on relatively narrow profit margins, with large volumes needed to the ventures economical.

If alternative proteins gain enough ground, "there may be a point where many large companies will start not just diversifying into alternative proteins but will start divesting from their existing holdings in protein," he said.

Dutkiewicz drew a comparison with large automotive companies now phasing out the internal combustion engine and transitioning to electric cars.

But, he cautioned, "we are at the very, very early stages of this".

Source: AFP/hs

Advertisement

Also worth reading

Advertisement