Commentary: Why would anyone ask Google for fashion advice?
Artificial intelligence is adept at identifying garments in photos and telling users more, similar to how fashion magazines break down celebrity looks, says an expert.
SYDNEY: The tech giants Amazon, Google and Facebook have all begun to use machine learning to give you tips on what to wear. Is fashion styling the next field to be disrupted by artificial intelligence (AI), or will the human eye remain supreme?
It’s too soon to know for sure, but understanding what machine learning is good at and how that overlaps with what fashion is all about can help us make some educated guesses.
GET THAT LOOK
One thing machine learning does very well is finding patterns and common features among groups of items.
Taking advantage of this, Google Lens and Amazon Style Snap can each identify a garment from a photo or video and then tell you a bit more, like how other people have worn it or where you can buy it.
This serves the same function as a fashion magazine taking a celebrity look and breaking it down into pieces.
By allowing consumers to recreate looks from movies, music videos, magazines and the runway, machine learning helps democratise elements of styling.
Amazon also goes further, linking garments to a database of looks from popular fashion influencers.
This offers the customer inspiration for building looks and conveniently gives the influencers a cut if the customer buys the clothes.
This system has great potential, but it can only be as good as the data that is fed into it.
A large and diverse database could bring out cultures and beauty standards that are not often seen in magazines or television, allowing people to find their tribe. But a narrower collection of sources will only produce more of the same.
THE STYLIST IN THE MACHINE
The next step in computer fashion – using AI to offer styling judgements – has so far been less successful.
Amazon’s Echo Look is a voice-controlled camera that aims to function as a style assistant, comparing two photos using a machine learning algorithm and telling you which one scores better. So far it has received lacklustre reviews.
This service seems doomed to struggle, as it neglects many basic principles of fashion design.
For example, many looks from influencers only have a front view. How could you possibly style an outfit properly without the whole picture?
Most principles of styling also take into account the wearer’s body shape, how well-fitted their clothing is, their personality, and the occasion for which the garment is being worn. Context, symbolism, nostalgia, and personal preferences also play a role.
The AI assistant has no way to address these nuances. To succeed, the machine learning engineers will need to understand fashion better and find useful and tangible tasks for AI to perform.
Facebook’s experimental Fashion++ project goes further still, trying to tell you how to improve the outfit you wear.
The idea behind the software is to make small changes (known as minimal edits) to an outfit, such as tucking in a shirt, rolling up a sleeve, changing the length of a hem, or removing an accessory. Garments are defined as “fashionable” if they are popular on a database and the AI learns to edit looks to make them score more highly in this regard.
This relies on a massive oversimplification of how the craft of fashion design works. Simply mimicking elements of what is popular and putting them together is no guarantee for an aesthetically pleasing look.
There is no guarantee that the most popular look – the statistical “mode” – will be truly fashionable, or “à la mode”.
A SPY IN YOUR WARDROBE
As we start taking photos and streaming videos of what we desire, or begin uploading photos of ourselves in our underwear, we should keep in mind that our data is being stored and mined. Data-mining corporations can use our personal information to influence our behavior, or sell it to advertisers.
Even if you are unconcerned with your personal data being shared, AI products are likely to encourage needless consumption over the actual goal of making you look attractive.
Often when people seek the help of a stylist or a second opinion on their appearance, it is not even about the clothing. Some need validation or attention, or are set in their ways what makes them look attractive.
Fashion styling serves a whole range of functions: Creating a look of beauty, projecting power, attracting a romantic partner, or making the wearer feel special.
There is no guarantee that even a stylist and some new clothing can achieve these goals – an app barely stands a chance.
Mark Liu is a fashion and textiles designer, and a Chancellor’s Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Technology Sydney. This article first appeared in The Conversation.