Commentary: It's better to exercise before breakfast
Exercising before breakfast may lead to improved insulin response and increased fat burning, says an expert.
BATH: Exercise is recommended for people who are overweight or obese as a way to reduce their risk of developing type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
But people don’t always have time to exercise as much as they would like, so finding ways to increase the health benefits of exercise is important.
Our latest research has found a way to do just that, and it has to do with timing. This means you might be able to get away with doing less exercise if other commitments, such as family and work, always seem to get in the way.
BETTER FOR YOUR INSULIN LEVELS
To explain how this works, it helps to know a bit about insulin. Insulin is a hormone that helps control blood sugar levels.
One of the main effects of insulin after a meal is to allow sugar in the blood to be transported into muscle, where it can then be stored or used as a fuel for energy.
When people don’t exercise enough and become overweight or obese, their bodies have to produce more insulin for the hormone to have this important effect. In other words, they become less sensitive to insulin.
This is one of the reasons why being overweight increases the risk of getting type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
One of the main health benefits of exercise is that it improves our response to insulin and we can better control our blood sugar levels – even if we do not see this change happening. It is now becoming clear that when we eat in relation to exercise could be important for this insulin response.
Our study looked at the responses to six weeks of exercise, which was supervised cycling for 50 minutes, three times a week.
In one group, overweight or obese men exercised before breakfast (fasted state) and showed an improved insulin response after the training. That is, they had to produce less insulin to control their blood sugar levels.
This suggests that they had a lower risk of diseases such as type 2 diabetes after the training. But the men who performed the same exercise after eating breakfast did not show an improved blood insulin response.
The men who exercised before breakfast also burned about double the amount of fat during exercise than the group who exercised after breakfast. Current evidence suggests that this increased fat burning during exercise may explain why that group showed improved health benefits.
BUT DON’T EXPECT TO LOSE MORE WEIGHT
A common misconception about exercise in the fasted state is that the increased fat burning will lead to increased weight loss. But for weight loss, the important factor is energy balance. This is the amount of energy eaten as food and drinks minus the amount of energy that is expended by the body, partly through exercise.
There is some evidence, that, over a period of 24 hours, skipping breakfast altogether and doing exercise may create a more negative energy balance, compared with eating breakfast and doing the same exercise.
Yet evidence also suggests that when it is only the timing of meals in relation to exercise that is changed (not skipping breakfast), the amount of weight lost will be similar even if fat burning is different. So increased fat burning during exercise does not lead to greater weight loss, unless the energy balance (for example, energy intake or energy expenditure) is different.
It is now important to repeat the study in women, although it is likely that the same effect would be shown with exercise before versus after breakfast. This is because eating breakfast before exercise reduces fat burning during the exercise, for both men and women.
This research was also for moderate-intensity endurance exercise, such as cycling and jogging, and the results don’t necessarily apply for high-intensity exercise or weight lifting.
Finding ways to increase the health benefits from exercise may help to reduce the increasing prevalence of diseases such as type 2 diabetes. The new research suggests that for your health it could be better to move your feet before you eat.
Rob Edinburgh is a PhD candidate in the Department for Health at the University of Bath. This article first appeared on The Conversation.