Commentary: Most teachers have been bullied by students or their parents and it's taking a toll
A survey found 83% of teachers in Australia disclosed a desire to leave the profession due to teacher-targeted student and parental bullying, La Trobe University lecturers, Paulina Billet, Edgar Burns, and Rochelle Fogelgarn point out.
MELBOURNE: Teachers are bullied daily by parents and students. They experience the kind of harassment that would be deemed unacceptable in most workplaces. But, in the case of teachers, such treatment is often dismissed as par for the course.
Radio presenter Jon Faine recently suggested we might be overstating students’ bullying behaviour towards teachers. He said:
What now is called bullying is what we used to regard as, you know, kind of giving teachers a hard time and teasing and being little horrible monsters.
We conducted a survey of 560 teachers across Australia in 2018. In the month-long social media campaign, 80 per cent of respondents recorded having been a victim of some form of student or parent bullying and harassment over the previous 9 to 12 months.
A separate survey also conducted in 2018 – which has been following school principals since 2011 – found one-third of Australian principals had been bullied or harassed. They reported both physical and verbal threats and abuse.
This doesn’t only happen in Australia. Studies in New Zealand, Luxembourg, the United States, Slovakia and South Africa all yield similar findings.
Student-to-teacher bullying and harassment has also been recorded in Taiwan, where students are taught to revere teachers, and in Finland, where the teaching profession is well regarded.
BULLIED BY STUDENTS
In our study, just over 70 per cent of participants reported having been bullied or harassed by a student in the last 12 months. Verbal aggression was the most common form of bullying.
Nearly 30 per cent of respondents recorded a student having sworn at them in the last 9 to 12 months, closely followed by yelling (28 per cent) and disparaging verbal comments (25.5 per cent).
Around 10 per cent of teachers had been hit or punched by a student in the last year, 12.5 per cent had a student damage their personal property and 16.6 per cent had a student stand over them or invade their personal space.
Female teachers experienced student bullying and harassment slightly more often than males – 71 per cent to 68.4 per cent.
Female teachers were more likely to experience students standing over them or invading their personal space, as well as students harassing them through phone calls or text messages.
Male teachers, on the other hand, were more likely to have students organise others against them, lie about them to get them in trouble, be discriminated against by students and have parents engaged to argue on a student’s behalf.
Nearly 60 per cent of teachers reported experiencing at least one incident of bullying and harassment by parents in the last 12 months. The most common were parents verbally disparaging a teacher, yelling, and arguing on their child’s behalf.
Female teachers bore the brunt of parental abuse (nearly 60 per cent, compared to 41 per cent for male teachers).
Physical attacks by parents on teachers were rare, with 8.8 per cent reporting a parent standing over or invading their personal space and just 1.1 per cent being hit or punched by a parent.
Bullying and harassment have a considerable impact on teachers.
Respondents in our survey reported severe repercussions for their mental health and well-being. A number of teachers said they were suffering symptoms of anxiety, depression and PTSD, including panic attacks and uncontrollable shaking.
Around 83 per cent of respondents who we interviewed disclosed a desire to leave the profession due to teacher-targeted student and parental bullying.
A male teacher who had been in the profession for nearly 15 years told us:
… bullying from students … contributed to me wanting to commit suicide. I felt worthless … It has taken years of support, encouragement and medical and spiritual intervention to enable me to teach full-time again.
Most teachers said they didn’t feel well supported when they made a report and that responses were often tokenistic. Many interviewees accused school management of allying themselves with students and parents rather than supporting the bullied teacher. One teacher told us:
I could deal with it if there was any form of support ... Teachers have no rights anymore and all we can realistically do is tell students they have detention or call their parents. Students don’t come to detention, then what!
WHAT CAN WE DO?
Bullying occurs in the context of a power imbalance. Teachers are understood to occupy a position of power over their students, which obscures the prevalence of teacher-targeted bullying in and out the classroom.
There was a feeling among respondents that student behaviour was contextualised in terms of teachers’ ability (or inability) to manage complicated situations. One teacher told us:
… I worry about grades on report cards and how parents will react. They no longer accept it, but instead try to influence and intimidate teachers to change the grades based on what they believe their child deserves.
Teachers also expressed dismay at their inability to create real and lasting change to bullying behaviour. Initial findings from our study call for more support by management and peak organisations for teachers who report even minor incidents.
Respondents suggested a code of conduct be created in schools. This would include a zero-tolerance policy and clear guidelines spelling out which behaviours are considered to be bullying and harassment. They suggested students and parents face penalties for breaching the code of conduct.
Teachers also called for stronger measures, such as the ability to expel students or ban parents from contacting teachers, to prevent aggressors from stepping back into classrooms or school grounds.
Paulina Billett is Lecturer, and Edgar Burns is Senior Lecturer in Sociology at La Trobe University. Rochelle Fogelgarn is Lecturer in Teacher Education in the same University. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation. Read it here.