Skip to main content



commentary Commentary

Commentary: The slow destruction of the American mind

To arrest America's decline, Americans must first accept how far the country has fallen behind in the last two years, Emeritus Professor of International Law at Purdue University Louis Rene Beres points out.

Commentary: The slow destruction of the American mind

Supporters of US President Donald Trump attend a rally in Springfield, Missouri, September 21, 2018. Picture taken September 21, 2018. (Photo: REUTERS/Mike Segar)

WEST LAFAYETTE, INDIANA: An open loathing of intellect has become substantially de rigeur for Donald Trump and his supporters. 

Accordingly, the nation’s chief executive regards terms like “intellectual” or “analytic” as epithets rather than positive attributes or prospectively gainful expectations.

While Trump did not create this demeaning subordination of the “mind,” it is nonetheless an integral component of his bitter and corrosive presidency. 

Furthermore, there are particular concerns. Above all, one must now inquire, how can an American president so willfully ignore the obvious foreign and domestic policy manipulations committed by his Russian counterpart and the deepening concerns shared by intelligence officials, investigators, congressional representatives of both parties, allies and other world leaders? 

Indeed, even in the absence of any recognisable “high thinking” in the White House, alarm builds that one superpower president risk becoming the pawn of another power.

READ: Last man standing Jim Mattis exits Trump's 'axis of adults', a commentary

Trump’s ascent to the American presidency did not arise in a vacuum. Rather, the country’s long history of distrust for intellect and science conveniently set the stage for such debilitating and portentous national leadership. In the words of poet W B Yeats:

There is no longer a virtuous nation, and the best of us live by candlelight.

We dare not speak of "tragedy.” Tragedy, unlike catastrophe and misfortune, is ennobling. It demands a victim, either individual or societal, who suffers markedly and undeservedly. 

It follows that a democratic and presumably virtuous nation that elected a blustering businessman and reality TV star can hardly be held blameless.

Donald Trump comes from the cut-throat world of Manhattan real estate, a celebrity and former reality TV star whose messy divorces and outlandish opinions were tabloid fodder. (Photo: AFP/Molly Riley)


Misled by the self-destructive syntax of “America First,” Americans have already forgotten that world politics is inevitably a system with US prosperity inextricably linked to the calculable well-being of other societies.

In Trump's cliche-ridden America, "we the people" are no longer shaped by common feelings of reverence or compassion, or even the tiniest hints of some clarifying analytic thought. 

Unsurprisingly, education failures represent a large part of the anti-intellectual problem. Even in the nation’s best colleges and universities, there is now far greater interest in studying “practical” matters than in learning history, government, literature, music or philosophy. And why not? In this country, true learning assuredly doesn’t “pay.”

In this feverishly disjointed era, the US president fervently encourages Americans to resist aggressively intellect, science, journalism and history. 

A sign showing major news organisations along with the words "fake news" is held up as US President Donald Trump speaks at a Make America Great Again Rally in Washington, Michigan April 28, 2018. (Photo: REUTERS/Joshua Roberts/Files) A sign showing major news organizations along with the words "fake news" is held up as U.S. President Donald Trump speaks at a Make America Great Again Rally in Washington, Michigan April 28, 2018. REUTERS/Joshua Roberts/Files

Often, too, even the most affluent US citizens separate themselves to inhabit the loneliest of places. Apart from their ownership of more conspicuously glittering stuff, there is little about greater wealth than can insulate these citizens from anomie, alienation and an utterly profound sense of meaninglessness.

“I belong, therefore I am” – this is not what philosopher Rene Descartes had in mind when he famously urged intellectual thought and purposeful doubt. It is also a sad credo, an unhesitatingly pathetic cry that social acceptance and certain related affections are roughly equivalent to physical survival and that even the sorely pretended pleasures of inclusion are desperately worth pursuing. 


At the same time, Americans shrug off the very real survival issue of others fleeing war in Syria or hopeless poverty in Central America. 

Although international law obliges the United States to oppose crimes of genocide and crimes against humanity, Trump remains silent on irremediable war crimes committed by Syria – this despite the fact that international law represents an incorporated part of the law of the United States. 

READ: When doors to migration slam shut, a commentary

In the words of Justice Horace Gray delivering the 1900 US Supreme Court judgment in Paquete Habana:

International law is part of our law, and must be ascertained and administered by the courts of justice of appropriate jurisdiction.

For most of our young people, learning has become a reluctantly required and inconvenient commodity, nothing more. 

At the same time, commodities exist for one overriding purpose. They are there, much like the newly minted college graduates themselves, to be marketed, bought and sold.

Though faced with distinctly genuine threats of war, illness, impoverishment and terror, vast millions of Americans still choose to distract and amuse themselves with assorted forms of morbid excitement, public scandal and the thoroughly inane repetitions of an authentically illiterate political discourse. 

US President Donald Trump has ordered an immediate troop withdrawal from war-torn Syria (Photo: AFP/-)

Not a day goes by that we don't notice some premonitory sign of impending catastrophe. 

Still, this self-anesthetised nation continues to impose upon its exhausted and manipulated people a shamelessly open devaluation of disciplined thought.  


Soon, even if the United States should somehow manage to avoid nuclear war and nuclear terrorism, the swaying of the American ship will become so violent that even the hardiest lamps will be overturned. Then, the phantoms of great ships of state, once laden with silver and gold, may no longer lie forgotten. 

READ: The stalemate over US government shutdown has politically damaged the president, a commentary

Instead, citizens will finally understand that the circumstances that once sent the great compositions of Homer, Maimonides, Goethe, Milton, Shakespeare, Freud and Kafka to join the disintegrating works of forgotten poets were neither unique nor transient.

In an 1897 essay titled On Being Human, Woodrow Wilson, later president of Princeton and the United States, inquired coyly about the authenticity of America. 

Is it even open to us to choose to be genuine?

This president answered “yes,” but only if we first refused to stoop to join the inglorious “herds” of mass society. 

Wilson describes the challenges: “Once it was a simple enough matter to be a human being, but now it is deeply difficult; because life was once simple, but is now complex, confused, multifarious. Haste, anxiety, preoccupation, the need to specialise and make machines of ourselves, have transformed the once simple world, and we are apprised that it will not be without effort that we shall keep the broad human traits which have so far made the earth habitable.”

Supporters rally with US President Donald Trump at Middle Georgia Regional Airport in Macon, Georgia, US November 4, 2018. (Photo: REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst) Supporters rally with U.S. President Donald Trump at Middle Georgia Regional Airport in Macon, Georgia, U.S. November 4, 2018. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst

READ: Donald Trump, a truly historic president, a commentary

In all societies, the meticulous care of individual "souls" is critically important. In principle, there can be a better "American soul"but not until Americans first affirm a prior obligation to shun the unsustainable and inter-penetrating seductions of mass culture, rank imitation, shallow thinking, organised mediocrity and as corollary a manifestly predatory presidential politics of “rallies”.

“This is the dead land,” intones T S Eliot in The Hollow Men. Here, as the prophetic poet already understood, those still living must reluctantly plan to receive “the supplication of a dead man's hand”. 

For the steadily weakening United States, now in cascading moral and physical decline, there does exist a more promising and dignified orientation, but it would require more conscious acceptance of how far the nation has fallen during the first years of Trump’s presidency.

Louis Rene Beres is the author of many books and articles dealing with international relations and international law. He also is Emeritus Professor of International Law at Purdue University. This commentary first appeared in Yale Global Online. 

Source: CNA/nr(sl)


Also worth reading