Skip to main content



commentary Commentary

Commentary: The US economy is benefiting from a global slump

This dirty secret in economics is that low interest rates are benefiting US companies, says economist Todd G Buchholz.

SAN DIEGO, California: There is a dirty little secret in economics today. The United States has benefited – and continues to benefit – from the global slump. 

The US economy is humming along, even while protesters in the United Kingdom hurl milkshakes at Brexiteers, French President Emmanuel Macron confronts nihilist yellow-vested marchers, and Chinese tech firms such as Huawei fear being frozen out of foreign markets.

Last year, the US economy grew by 2.9 per cent, while the eurozone expanded by just 1.8 per cent, giving President Donald Trump even more confidence in his confrontational style. But relatively strong US growth amid sluggishness elsewhere is not what economics textbooks would predict. 

Protesters wearing yellow vests attend a demonstration in front of the Sacre-Coeur Basilica of Montmartre during the Act XIX (the 19th consecutive national protest on Saturday) of the "yellow vests" movement in Paris, France, March 23, 2019. (Photo: REUTERS/Benoit Tessier)

READ: The yellow vest, a symbol of a rising political movement in France, a commentary

Whatever happened to the tightly integrated world economy that the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank have been advocating – and more recently extolling – since World War II?


The US economy is in a temporary but potent phase in which weakness abroad lifts spirits at home. But this economic euphoria has nothing to do with Trump-era spite and malice, and much to do with interest rates.

Borrowing costs are currently lower than at any time since the founding of the US Federal Reserve in 1913, or in the UK’s case since the Bank of England was established in 1694. The 10-year US Treasury bond is yielding about 2.1 per cent, and in April, the streaming service Netflix issued bonds at a rate of just 5.4 per cent.

If a Rip Van Winkle economist were to wake up today after a decades-long sleep and see only those numbers, he or she would assume that one-fifth of Americans were unemployed and standing in lines outside soup kitchens. Instead, the US jobless rate is at its lowest level since Neil Armstrong took his famous first step onto the Moon’s surface 50 years ago.

The idea that the US wins in a global slump might sound like the sardonic musing of some unreconstructed Marxist in the dingy corner of a faculty lounge. 

But such a view is not ideological. Rather, global interest rates are scraping the floor because GDP growth outside the US is so sluggish.

A US factory. (File photo: AFP/Robyn Beck) Sluggish US inflation is something that has baffled and worried economists given the very low unemployment rate which would normally drive prices higher AFP/Robyn Beck

Persistently low interest rates and weak inflation bring multiple benefits to the US economy. For starters, American consumers, whose real (inflation-adjusted) wages are finally increasing after decades of stagnation, are seeing all sorts of bargains. 

When I visited an Apple store a few days ago, an employee at the repair counter told me that I could finance a new iPhone at zero interest. Car dealers are offering zero-interest financing, too.

The US stock market has soared because yields on bank certificates of deposit (CDs) look so puny. When I was a kid in the 1970s, my mother placed our family savings in a bank and received not only a 6 per cent return, but also a blender. 

Today, a six-month bank CD might pay only one-third of a percentage point. And my mother can no longer expect a blender or even a lollipop from the bank in return for parking her money there.


Finally, low interest rates mean that US businesses can obtain nearly free financing when they purchase equipment. 

As a result of low borrowing costs and new tax write-offs, the US economy added 215,000 new machine manufacturing jobs in 2018. And foreign investors realise that new equipment will make US companies more competitive.

But surely, the textbooks insist, a hobbled global economy will squeeze US exports. That is true – especially when combined with China’s new tariffs on American goods and a strong dollar, which makes US exports more expensive internationally.

China has ramped up tariffs in US$60 billion of US imports and there were warnings that Beijing could look at other ways of hitting Washington, such as dumping its Treasury holdings. (Photo: AFP/STR) China has ramped up tariffs in $60 billion of US imports and there were warnings that Beijing could look at other ways of hitting Washington, such as dumping its Treasury holdings AFP/STR

READ: It's the US that has miscalculated in this trade war, a commentary

Still, exports make up only 12 per cent of the US economy, and nearly one-third of them go to Canada and Mexico, whose economies have been doing okay. Moreover, many of the most valuable US exports are “must-have” items (or oligopolistic goods made by only a few companies), such as Boeing jets, Qualcomm chips, or Apple iPhones. 

It is hard even for dejected Frenchmen or angst-ridden Germans to do without these.

The buoyancy of the US economy worries policymakers in other countries. They would prefer if the US stumbled along beside them and was forced to concoct cooperative ways of boosting global growth. 

Instead, Trump needles rather than wheedles for trade deals, and happily pockets the benefits to the US economy that result from doldrums abroad.

No one knows when Trump’s trade needling will stop, of course. But as long as inflation remains a distant spectre, America’s economy will continue to enjoy this unusual type of growth.

Todd G Buchholz has served as director of economic policy under President George H W Bush and as managing director of the Tiger hedge fund. He was awarded Harvard University’s Allyn Young Teaching Prize in economics and is the author of New Ideas from Dead Economists and The Price of Prosperity.


Also worth reading