commentary Commentary
Commentary: America’s fragile economy under Trump
The outcome of the next US election will bear directly on people’s welfare, and there can be no question that Biden would want to restore the American economy to its former glory, says an observer.
Donald Trump and Joe Biden display radically different styles as they court American voters in the 2020 US elections. (Photo: AFP/Mandel Ngan and Olivier Douliery)
NEW YORK: Commentators have offered many reasons why one should vote in November for Joe Biden, the Democratic nominee for US president.
Yet the economic dimension of the election has been of little interest to pundits, and few, if any, economists speaking on the subject have bothered to highlight how the outcome bears directly on people’s welfare.
But the economy is the stage on which people work in the hope of gaining personal development and the satisfaction of succeeding. It isn’t just about the money.
READ: Commentary: US Supreme Court drama makes for a nastier presidential election
READ: Commentary: Donald Trump doesn't deserve all blame for poor US response to COVID-19
THE ECONOMIC CASE AGAINST TRUMP
The economic case for Biden begins with the economic case against President Donald Trump.
Consider Trump’s costly corporate tax cut. It did not deliver the investment and growth promised, and resulted in fiscal deficits during the first three years of his presidency.
This has set a precedent for unnecessary deficits in future administrations. Of course, the deficit incurred more recently in responding to the pandemic was unavoidable and, under the circumstances, beneficial.
His habitual threats to American businesses have added new uncertainty to investment and trade decisions, inhibiting enterprise and innovation at a time when they are desperately needed.
READ: Commentary: No winners in a US-China technology divide
Trump’s crusade to reduce the harmless trade deficit has shrunk world trade, thus worsening the efficiency of resource allocation at home and abroad.
His populist rhetoric has not translated into better pay for less advantaged workers or victims of discrimination. He has sought to erase any sense of economic justice.
He has done little to address appallingly low wage rates for those at the bottom or the terrible living standards that these wages afford. And he has done nothing to support the eradication of statistical discrimination – racial, gender, and more.
His weakening of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) has heavily affected people with low incomes.
Trump’s insistence that climate change is a hoax has put the world economy and the viability of the planet in further danger. He says that the wildfires ravaging the American West are the result of poor “forest management”.
READ: Commentary: California wildfires signal arrival of a planetary fire age
LISTEN: Feeding the planet and heating it up: how agriculture impacts our environment
DEPRECIATION OF AMERICAN MORALE
In attacking institutions from the FBI to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Trump is hollowing out the governmental structure. In imposing pointless obstacles that lead to trade wars, he has alienated America’s allies.
There are other outrages too numerous to mention. But one of the most appalling was his effort to eliminate the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) programme for undocumented aliens who were brought to the US as children, who, after being raised and educated in America, now face deportation.
Today, a great many people support Biden on these grounds and others. Trump stands in the way of the nation regaining a sense of flourishing, equity and social harmony.
But it is not clear he could be defeated on these grounds alone. Many Americans dread a government devoted to ministering to a melange of social groups without a thought to core matters of economic growth and job satisfaction.
But there is also a positive argument for supporting Biden.
READ: Commentary: Trump will get beaten by Biden by millions of votes but plans to win anyway
REDEMPTION OF THE AMERICAN DREAM
First, Biden understands that in America there is still a crushing disparity between the wages of the seriously less-advantaged and those paid to middle-income people – and payments for single mothers do not change that.
Biden, having grown up in the steelmaking region of Pennsylvania, can hardly be blind to the deprivations and pain of low-paid workers. So, if elected, we would have a president responsive to legislative initiatives for subsidies designed to pull up these workers’ meagre compensation.
READ: Commentary: The welcome lack of enthusiasm for Joe Biden
Biden is also attentive to the existential threat of continuing climate change. There is a vast litany of problems, such as the burning of fossil fuels causing increased levels of carbon dioxide and rising temperatures.
Addressing these problems will require government intervention and international cooperation, such as that mandated by the 2015 Paris climate agreement, from which Trump withdrew the US.
No one can doubt that, if elected, Biden would be eager to play a central role in the resumption of the battle against global warming.
LISTEN: When it comes to climate change, why is CO2 public enemy number one?
READ: Commentary: The hope for change in a Biden-Harris US election win
Finally, Americans are living with the virtual stagnation of the economy since the early 1970s (interrupted for about a decade by the Information Revolution). This continuing malaise lies behind wage earners’ increased frustration over their relative standing in wage distribution – a sentiment that, more than anything else, accounted for Trump’s rise.
There can be no question that a President Biden would want to restore the economy to its former glory.
Trump has gravely weakened the nation’s economy, while Biden has shown over his life that he cares about people’s chances for prosperity and rewarding lives – for achieving the American Dream.
Edmund Phelps, the 2006 Nobel laureate in economics and Director of the Center on Capitalism and Society at Columbia University, is the author of Mass Flourishing and co-author of Dynamism.
