Commentary: Djarot Saiful Hidayat, the man for every North Sumatra voter

Commentary: Djarot Saiful Hidayat, the man for every North Sumatra voter

North Sumatra stands out as a key political power centre in Indonesia’s upcoming gubernatorial and mayoral elections. Aisyah Llewellyn says Djarot Saiful Hidayat, former deputy to Ahok and former deputy governor of Jakarta, stands in good stead to win the governor seat there.

Djarot Saiful Hidayat governor
Jakarta's then deputy governor Djarot Saiful Hidayat talks to the media after visiting governor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama or better known as Ahok on May 9, 2017. (Photo: AFP/Goh Chai Hin)

JAKARTA: In January, Indonesia’s Partai Demokrasi Indonesia Perjuangan (PDIP), or the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle, made an announcement.

Djarot Saiful Hidayat, the former governor of Jakarta and one of the most high-profile politicians in Indonesia, would run for governor of North Sumatra in elections to be held in June.

To many, this news came as a surprise. 

“Djarot did not decide to run in North Sumatra himself”, Jumiran Abdi, the PDIP deputy head in North Sumatra, told me in his office in Medan. “PDIP made the decision as a party. He was chosen due to his great popularity as a politician.”

Djarot is a well-known political figure in Indonesia whose profile has grown nationally in recent years. He was the mayor of Blitar, East Java, for a decade from 2000, and later one of the main campaign advisers in Jokowi’s successful 2014 presidential campaign.

Djarot then became the deputy governor of Jakarta and governor for a short time, marking him as an accomplished and experienced politician.

But Djarot’s record was blemished when he and Ahok, a Christian and Chinese-Indonesian, sought another term in the Jakarta gubernatorial elections last year, only to be defeated by Anies Baswedan and Sandiaga Uno.

Perhaps at this point Djarot would have faded into political obscurity had it not been for Ahok’s subsequent trial and imprisonment for blasphemy. 

With Ahok incarcerated, Djarot stood in as governor of Jakarta from June to October, until Anies Baswedan was sworn in.

Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan and his deputy Sandiaga Uno wave to reporters before a swearing-in
Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan and his deputy Sandiaga Uno wave to reporters before the swearing-in at the Presidential Palace in Jakarta, Indonesia on Oct 16, 2017. (Photo: REUTERS/Beawiharta)

Djarot’s rise to national fame followed widespread protests across the country against Ahok’s conviction. As crowds of more than a thousand people poured into the area in front of City Hall in Jakarta, Djarot wept openly while singing the Indonesian national anthem.

Where many had wondered if Djarot, a devout Muslim, would distance himself from Ahok following his conviction for insulting Islam, this gutsy move endeared him to many political observers and voters. Djarot's personal popularity underpins PDIP hopes to propel him to the governorship of North Sumatra.


North Sumatra is Indonesia’s fourth most populous province, which makes it an important political power centre. It is also one of the most multicultural provinces in the country, with a mixed population of Batak, Javanese, Chinese, Tamil, Minang and Malay residents.

Djarot could appeal to a wide cross section of voters. This is where voting is a numbers game. Indonesian voters often tend to choose candidates of the same ethnicity and religion as themselves.

Indonesian policemen carry their injured colleague as hardline Muslim groups protest against Jakart
Indonesian policemen carry their injured colleague amid protests by hardline Muslim groups against Ahok in 2017. (Photo: Reuters)

Djarot is Javanese, as are about 30 per cent of North Sumatran residents. His support for Ahok could mean he may receive widespread support from Chinese voters, who account for around 6 per cent of the population.

Djarot's running mate, Sihar Sitorus, is Batak and also a Christian, and a smart choice for deputy in an effort to pick up Christian and Batak voters.

In other Southeast Asian countries, a candidate's origin and religion wouldn’t matter as much, but as the Jakarta gubernatorial race showed, identity has occupied an increasingly important space in election campaigns in Indonesia.

According to Kardina Karim Hamado, a lecturer in politics and international relations at Fajar University, Djarot’s chances in North Sumatra could be better than in Jakarta:

If you compare politics in the context of religion in both places, North Sumatra has large Muslim and non-Muslim communities … Sumatran voters are known to be more accommodating to candidates from outside North Sumatra. They have previously elected governors in North Sumatra who were not local residents.


Djarot’s main opponent, former Lieutenant-General Edy Rahmayadi, was born in Sabang in Aceh. 

Some communities in North Sumatra, particularly non-Muslim groups, worry that he may try to enforce more conservative policies on North Sumatra in the model of Aceh, the only part of Indonesia that has Shariah laws.

Rahmayadi also has a controversial record following a dispute over land rights, which saw forced evictions of residents from Deli Serdang and could make him unattractive to some voters. Yet he remains a formidable candidate supported by four other political parties.

Another stumbling block for Djarot and Sihar will be having to start their campaign from scratch. They are newcomers to the political scene in North Sumatra and will need to demonstrate that they understand the ethnic and religious complexities of the region.

This is something Djarot has already started to address. 

In one of his first official appearances in Medan, Djarot said he was ready to serve all the residents of North Sumatra, telling an appreciative crowd at Sobat Café: “We are here to serve the Karo, the Mandailing, the Toba, the Indians, the Chinese, the Javanese ... everyone”.

In this sense, PDIP is organising a cohesive campaign based on inclusivity. While Djarot may appeal to Javanese and Chinese-Indonesian voters, he cannot rely on those votes alone if he wants to win.

This inclusive message of governing in everyone’s best interests may convince undecided voters to support a political outsider of a different religion or ethnicity.

The PDIP's end strategy might be to pitch Djarot as the “every man’s candidate” in the race. 

They would do well to keep reminding voters of something that the PDIP’s Abdi already appears to recognise when he said:

North Sumatra is like a mini-Indonesia. Everyone is welcome here and that includes Djarot.

Aisyah Llewellyn is a writer based in Medan who writes about Indonesian politics and culture. This commentary first appeared in Lowy Institute's blog The Interpreter. Read the original commentary here.

Source: CNA/sl