Tesla boss Elon Musk wins defamation trial over 'pedo guy' tweet

Tesla boss Elon Musk wins defamation trial over 'pedo guy' tweet

Tesla co-founder Elon Musk leaves the Los Angeles federal courthouse through a back door on December
Tesla co-founder Elon Musk leaves the Los Angeles federal courthouse through a back door on December 3, 2019 AFP/Apu Gomes

LOS ANGELES: Tesla boss Elon Musk emerged victorious on Friday (Dec 6) from a defamation trial as a federal court jury swiftly rejected the US$190 million defamation claim brought against him by a British cave explorer who Musk had branded a "pedo guy" on Twitter.

The unanimous verdict by a jury of five women and three men was returned after about 45 minutes of deliberation on the fourth day of Musk's trial. The trial has been closely watched by legal experts because it is believed to be the first major defamation lawsuit by a private individual to go to trial over tweets.

The outcome was a triumph for Musk, whose mercurial behaviour in a number of instances last year came under close scrutiny from federal regulators and shareholders of Tesla, his Silicon Valley-based electric car manufacturer.

READ: Musk's defamation win may reset legal landscape for social media

L Lin Wood, a high-profile trial lawyer who led the legal team for the plaintiff, Vernon Unsworth, said the jury's decision signals a higher legal threshold for challenging libellous material on social media.

"This verdict puts everyone's reputation at risk," Wood told reporters after the verdict was announced.

Musk, 48, who had testified during the first two days of the trial in his own defence and returned to court on Friday to hear closing arguments, exited the courtroom after the verdict and said: "My faith in humanity is restored."

Outside the courthouse, Unsworth, 64, said he was resigned to his defeat. "I accept the jury's verdict, take it on the chin and get on with my life."

British cave diver Vernon Unsworth talks to reporters with attorneys after a U.S. District Court ju
British cave diver Vernon Unsworth talks to reporters with attorneys after a U.S. District Court jury found Tesla Inc chief executive Elon Musk not liable for defamation damages, in Los Angeles

INTERACTIVE SPECIAL: Thai cave rescue – a look at the unprecedented rescue operation

Wood said his client went "toe to toe with a billionaire bully", echoing a phrase from his summation earlier in court, and indicated to reporters that an appeal was doubtful.

"It's not the verdict we wanted. But it's the end of the road and we now close this chapter," Wood said.

He said he nevertheless saw the lawsuit as meaningful in helping erase the stain he said Unsworth's reputation suffered.

During the course of the trial, Musk testified under oath that his use of the term "pedo guy" - slang for paedophile - was never meant to be taken literally, and he apologised to Unsworth for the comment from the witness stand.

SUBMARINE SQUABBLE

The case stems from a public quarrel between Musk and Unsworth, a British diver who lives part-time in Thailand and gained fame for his leading role in coordinating the successful rescue of 12 boys and their soccer coach from a flooded cave in that country in July 2018.

Unsworth had chided Musk in a CNN interview for delivering a mini-submarine, which was never used, to the site of the Tham Luang Nang Non cave system. Unsworth called Musk's intervention a "PR" stunt and said the high-tech entrepreneur should "stick his submarine where it hurts".

Musk responded two days later on Twitter with three posts that became the basis of the defamation case. The first questioned Unsworth's role in the rescue, while the second said: "Sorry pedo guy, you really did ask for it," using a slang term of paedophile.

The third tweet, in reply to a follower who asked Musk about the second tweet, said: "Bet ya a signed dollar it's true."

READ: One year after Thai cave rescue, grieving wife of dead diver struggles to move on

READ: Miracle of 'Wild Boars' rescue transforms Thai cave into tourist draw

Wood said during his summation that Musk's tweets were akin to a "nuclear bomb" that would overshadow Unsworth's relationships and job prospects for years to come and urged jurors to teach the Tesla chief executive and SpaceX founder a lesson by awarding Unsworth US$190 million, including US$150 million in punitive damages.

Two days earlier, under questioning on the witness stand, Musk had estimated his net worth at US$20 billion.

But the jury was apparently swayed by the arguments put forth by Musk's attorney, Alex Spiro, who said the tweets in question arose from an argument between two men and amounted to an off-hand insult that no one could be expected to take seriously.

"In arguments you insult people," he said. "There is no bomb. No bomb went off."

Defendant Attorney Alex Spiro speaks to reporters after a U.S. District Court jury found Tesla Inc
Defendant Attorney Alex Spiro speaks to reporters after a U.S. District Court jury found Tesla Inc chief executive Elon Musk not liable for defamation damages, in Los Angeles

Spiro also said Unsworth failed to demonstrate he suffered any harm from Musk's comments.

US District Judge Stephen Wilson had said the case hinged on whether a reasonable person would take Musk's Twitter statements to mean he was actually calling Unsworth a paedophile.

To win, Unsworth needed to show that Musk was negligent in publishing a falsehood that clearly identified the plaintiff and caused him harm. "Actual malice" on Musk's part, a high standard in defamation cases, did not need to be proven since the judge deemed Unsworth a private individual, not a public figure.

The trial revived discussion of Musk’s erratic behaviour in 2018, when he used Twitter to float a leveraged buyout proposal for Tesla that was scuttled, ultimately paying US$20 million to settle a Securities and Exchange Commission complaint.

For most of 2019, Musk, who has nearly 30 million Twitter followers, has largely kept his public comments focused on Tesla’s new models and improved profitability and on the technical progress of his aerospace company, SpaceX.

Source: Reuters

Bookmark