Commentary: Are US treasury bonds still a safe investment bet?

Commentary: Are US treasury bonds still a safe investment bet?

For the first time in living memory, investors lack a quiet port where they can find shelter from the storm, says Professor Benjamin J Cohen.

A US$100 bill and Japanese 10,000 yen notes
A US$100 bill and Japanese 10,000 yen notes. (Photo: REUTERS/Shohei Miyano)

SANTA BARBARA: With equities slumping, exchange-rate volatility increasing, and political risks intensifying, financial markets around the world have hit a rough patch.

During times like these, international investors generally grow cautious and prioritise safety over returns, so money flees to “safe havens” that can provide secure, liquid investment-grade assets on a sufficiently large scale.

But there are no obvious safe havens today. For the first time in living memory, investors lack a quiet port where they can find shelter from the storm.

WHAT ABOUT US TREASURY BONDS?

Historically, the safe haven par excellence was the United States, in the form of Treasury bonds backed by the “full faith and credit” of the US government. As one investment strategist put it back in 2012:

When people are worried, all road lead to Treasuries.

The bursting of the US real-estate bubble in 2007 offers a case in point. No one doubted that the US was the epicentre of the global financial crisis.

But rather than flee the US, capital actually flooded into it. In the last three months of 2008, net purchases of US assets reached a half-trillion dollars – three times more than that of the preceding nine months combined.

To be sure, some of these dollar claims were due to the fact that foreign banks and institutional investors needed greenbacks to cover their funding needs after interbank and other wholesale short-term markets seized up.

But that was hardly the only reason why portfolio managers piled into the US. Much of the increased demand was due to sheer fear. At a time when nobody knew how bad things might get, the US was widely seen as the safest bet.

US Treasury
Seal of the US Treasury building in Washington, DC. (File photo: AFP/Paul J Richards)

READ: Expect nerve-wracking risks in the global economy to emerge this year, a commentary

SHAKEN CONFIDENCE IN US GOVERNMENT CREDIT RATING

But this was before the arrival of US President Donald Trump, who has managed to undermine confidence in the dollar to an unprecedented degree. In addition to abandoning any notion of fiscal responsibility, Trump has spent his first two years in office attacking international institutions and picking fights with US allies.

To be sure, even before Trump, confidence in the dollar suffered a blow in 2011, when Standard & Poor’s downgraded Treasury securities by one notch in response to a near-shutdown of the US government. That episode was triggered by a standoff between then-President Barack Obama and congressional Republicans over a routine proposal to raise the federal debt ceiling.

Today, however, investors have even more reason to worry about the US government’s credit rating. In 2018 alone, the US government was shut down three times, and it remains in a partial shutdown to this day, owing to Trump’s demand for funds to build a “big, beautiful” wall on the border with Mexico.

READ: That’s the sound of financial markets waking up to a looming crisis, a commentary

US stocks have wiped out all their 2018 gains amid rising concerns about the American economy's
US stocks have wiped out all their 2018 gains amid rising concerns about the American economy's growth prospects, which prompted the Fed to signal it might pause interest rate hikes (Photo: AFP/SPENCER PLATT)

WHAT ABOUT EUROPE?

Where can investors go if not the US? The eurozone might seem like a logical alternative. After the dollar, the euro is the world’s most widely used currency. And, taken together, the capital markets of the eurozone’s 19 member states are close in size to the US market.

But Europe has troubles of its own. Economic growth is slowing, not least in Germany, and the risk of a banking crisis in Italy – the eurozone’s fourth-largest economy – looms on the horizon.

READ: 20 years later, the euro stumbles forward, a commentary

Worse still is the uncertainty over Brexit, which could prove highly disruptive if the United Kingdom crashes out of the European Union without a divorce agreement. Needless to say, Britain, too, can be ruled out as a safe haven, at least until the Brexit fiasco is resolved.

What about the Swiss franc? Though its attractions are obvious, Switzerland’s financial markets are simply too small to serve as an adequate substitute for the US.

READ: Theresa May’s breathtaking defeat points to a Brexit delay, a commentary

WHAT ABOUT ASIAN MARKETS?

That leaves Japan. With its abundant supply of government bonds, it is the biggest single market for public debt outside the US. The question for portfolio managers, though, is whether it is really safe to invest in a country where government debt exceeds 230 per cent of GDP.

For comparison, the public debt-to-GDP ratio in the US is around 88 per cent; and even in troubled Italy, it is no more than 130 per cent. Admittedly, the market for Japanese government debt is more stable than most, owing to the fact that much of it is held by domestic savers (which is to say, it is safely tucked under the mattress).

But Japan is an ageing country with an economy that has remained almost stagnant for a quarter-century. Investors would be right to wonder where it will find the resources to continue servicing its massive debt overhang.

FILE PHOTO:  A man looks at an electronic board showing the Nikkei stock index outside a brokerage
A man looks at an electronic board showing the Nikkei stock index outside a brokerage in Tokyo, Jan 7, 2019. (File photo: Reuters/Kim Kyung-Hoon)

And then there is China, with the world’s third-largest national market for public debt. Certainly, the supply of assets in China is ample.

But the Chinese market is so tightly controlled that it is essentially the opposite of a safe haven. It will be a long time before global investors even consider putting much faith in Chinese securities.

With secure ports becoming scarce, investors will become increasingly jittery. They will be inclined to move funds at the slightest sign of danger, which will add substantially to market volatility. Today’s rough patch is probably here to stay.

Benjamin J Cohen is Professor of International Political Economy at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and author of Currency Power: Understanding Monetary Rivalry.

Source: Project Syndicate/sl

Bookmark