Commentary: Should you record your consultation with your doctor?

Commentary: Should you record your consultation with your doctor?

Health professionals including doctors and nurses believe consultation recordings benefit patients, and improve the care they are able to provide, say the Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre's Amelia Hyatt and Ruby Lipson-Smith.

Doctor patient
(Photo: Pixabay/Rawpixel)

MELBOURNE: You’re in a consultation with your doctor and you’ve just been told you have cancer. You’re in shock, and find it difficult to take in anything else the doctor says during the remainder of the appointment.

Research shows receiving bad news can impact people’s ability to understand and absorb information. Specifically, it affects the processing of information and memory formation.

People who are unwell and managing difficult health situations will often find it hard to remember important and complex medical information. This might include their diagnosis, prognosis, treatment plans, appointments, and when to take their medication.

HELP TO REMEMBER COMPLEX INFORMATION

Since the 1970s, researchers have been experimenting with audio recording medical consultations to combat this problem.

Many studies and reviews since then have found patients who are given personalised recordings of their medical consultations feel their recall and understanding is improved.

We don’t yet have evidence that directly links the recording of medical consultations with improved health outcomes. 

But we know people who understand and remember important medical information are better placed to remember to attend scheduled appointments, to decide on the best treatment options, and to take their medication correctly.

READ: Unable to look sideways? Unusual signs of diabetes often unnoticed, ignored or denied, a commentary

This is commonly referred to as health literacy, and people with higher health literacy are known to have improved health outcomes. 

So we have good reason to believe recording medical appointments might positively impact people’s long-term health.

Skin doctor
File photo of a dermatologist examining a patient. (Photo: Joe Raedle/Getty Images/AFP)

BENEFITS TO PATIENTS

While most research around medical consultation recordings has been done with people diagnosed with cancer, the process could help any person in any medical situation.

People who speak English as a second language find recordings of medical consultations particularly useful.

And consultation recordings are not just useful for patients. 

Family members and friends often play a significant part in the care of a loved one who is unwell. Recordings give them the opportunity to be involved and informed – even if they cannot attend the appointment in person – as recordings are easily shared.

IMPROVED TRUST

Patients in a recent study described using the recording to replay important sections to their family, to remind themselves of words to look up, and to prompt questions to ask their doctor.

In addition, recordings have been shown to improve patient trust and satisfaction with their doctor.

READ: Are complaints against doctors destroying the doctor-patient relationship? A commentary

Health professionals including doctors and nurses believe consultation recordings benefit patients, and improve the care they are able to provide.

Patients have described which appointments they feel are most useful to record. These include appointments at diagnosis of a health condition, appointments where important information is discussed, or appointments where treatment plans are made. 

Others think recording every appointment would be useful for them.

The great thing about recordings is they are under the control of the patient, so they can be made and used in the way that suits the person best.

Retired French doctor Jean-Francois Rechner, 67, measures the blood pressure of a patient during a
Retired French doctor Jean-Francois Rechner, 67, measures the blood pressure of a patient during a consultation at the 'Service Medical de Proximite' clinic in Laval, France, November 8, 2018. Picture taken November 8, 2018. REUTERS/Stephane Mahe

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS

People are already using their mobile phones to record their doctors’ appointments. One study from the UK found 69 per cent of people were interested in recording consultations on their phones.

Although this is usually done with the doctor’s permission, it’s sometimes done covertly. This may diminish the trust and openness that should characterise any doctor-patient relationship, and may even be unlawful in some states.

READ: How should we regulate doctors and protect patients in a complex world? A commentary

So you should always seek your doctor’s permission before recording.

Importantly, if a health service endorses and provides a means for you to record your medical consultations, the recording is seen as forming part of your medical record.

Amelia Hyatt is Senior Researcher at the Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre. Ruby Lipson-Smith is Research Officer at the same centre. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation. Read it here.


Source: CNA/sl

Bookmark