Commentary: A global revival of nationalists looms, as their resonance with voters grows

Commentary: A global revival of nationalists looms, as their resonance with voters grows

Nationalist political parties are on the rise and taking inspiration from each other, says Financial Times' Gideon Rachman.

LONDON: An international nationalist movement sounds like a contradiction. 

Nationalists are concerned above all by the fortunes of their own tribe. International co-operation does not come naturally to them. And yet, despite this, the world is seeing the emergence of a “nationalist international”.

Nationalist political parties are on the rise across the west — and they are taking inspiration from each other and working together.

Donald Trump is central to this development. The US president is often portrayed as an isolated maverick on the world stage. But, in fact, he is emerging as the informal leader of an international movement. By shifting American politics in a more nationalist direction, Mr Trump has changed the tone of politics everywhere.


The US president already has ideological soulmates in Europe, where the key figures include Viktor Orban, the prime minister of Hungary (who came to power before Mr Trump), and Matteo Salvini, Italy’s deputy prime minister.

Europe’s nationalists include far-right parties that are now in coalition governments, such as Mr Salvini’s League and Austria’s Freedom Party. 

But nationalist themes have also been increasingly adopted by more traditional centre-right parties, such as Germany’s Christian Social Union (CSU), Britain’s Conservatives and Austria’s People’s party.

READ: Why Hungary's Viktor Orban is closing one of Europe's top-ranking, richest universities, a commentary.

READ: Turkey's Recep Erdogan won the elections but a more diverse parliament opens a new phase for the country, a commentary.

The nationalists’ dominant issue is usually immigration — and the need to defend the nation against “swarms” of migrants from outside the west. When it comes to economics, they are often drawn to Trump-style protectionism.

Italy's Interior Minister Matteo Salvini looks on during the news conference at the Viminale i
Italy's Interior Minister Matteo Salvini looks on during the news conference at the Viminale in Rome, Italy, June 20, 2018. (Photo: REUTERS/Stefano Rellandini)

These nationalists are also hostile to international institutions and treaties, which they regard as the playthings of a rootless, global elite.

The Trump administration has withdrawn from international treaties such as the Paris climate accord, and organisations like the UN Human Rights Council. The European nationalists focus their ire on the EU and the international rules governing the treatment of refugees.

READ: The exorbitant costs of America going it alone, a commentary.

Increasingly, they are looking to cooperate.

Sebastian Kurz, Austria’s chancellor, has mused about organising a “Berlin-Rome-Vienna” axis to fight illegal immigration. Richard Grenell, the US ambassador in Germany, has talked about empowering Trump-style “conservatives” across Europe. Steve Bannon, Mr Trump’s former chief strategist, convened meetings of nationalist parties in Rome during the Italian elections, writing later:

It’s hard not to feel we’re on the right side of history.

The nationalists are often fans of Vladimir Putin. The Russian president is admired as a tough guy who sticks up for his nation. His violation of international laws in the process is regarded as a plus — not a minus.

By contrast, the nationalists detest Angela Merkel, the German chancellor, and Justin Trudeau, the Canadian prime minister, who are seen as preachy internationalists, hopelessly soft-headed on the defining issue of immigration.


This nationalism is not confined to the west. In Delhi, recently, I had a long conversation with Jayant Sinha, a government minister. He argued that the Modi government rejects universalism, in favour of a defence of India’s unique culture.

“People feel their heritage is under siege,” he said, “in that sense we are part of a global narrative.”

Many liberal internationalists find it hard to accept that the nationalists are making progress partly because they have some genuine political insights.

Their emphasis on the enduring importance of the nation-state clearly resonates with voters. Demands for tougher control of illegal migration flow naturally from that idea — since the question of who is entitled to citizenship is central to national identity.

Europe’s nationalists, such as Mr Salvini, Mr Orban and Britain’s Nigel Farage, have capitalised on complaints that the EU grabbed too many of the traditional powers of the nation and controls everything from national budget deficits to citizenship rights.

The central demands of the new nationalists, such as control of immigration or protectionism, have a legitimate place in democratic politics. But the policies adopted by them, once they are in power, have quickly spun off into horrifying directions, such as the detention of migrant children in the US or Mr Salvini’s demand for a mass expulsion of the Roma population from Italy.

Salvadoran migrant Epigmenio Centeno and his sons pose for a photograph outside the shelter House o
Salvadoran migrant Epigmenio Centeno and his sons pose for a photograph outside the shelter House of the Migrant, after Epigmenio decided to stay with his children in Mexico due to U.S. President Donald Trump's child separation policy, in Ciudad Juarez. 


One key problem is that the nationalist emphasis on the nation-state usually has a strong cultural and racial element.

Once you start thinking of outsiders as less worthy than your compatriots — indeed, as people who “infest” your nation (in the words of President Trump) — than it becomes much easier to treat them brutally.

A second problem is that the new nationalists often ignore the complexity of the modern world.

International rules are not simply the product of the ideological preferences of an unmoored globalist elite. They are the necessary means to regulate the interactions of nations on everything from trade to travel.

Abolish all those fussy international laws and you are on the route to anarchy, a trade war — or a real war.

So while the nationalists are making common cause in taking on their liberal internationalist foes around the world, the “nationalist international” is intrinsically unstable. A world in which nation-states see each other above all as rivals is one that is primed for conflict.

© 2018 The Financial Times Ltd. All rights reserved. Please do not copy and paste FT articles and redistribute by email or post to the web.

Source: Financial Times/nr(sl)