Commentary: India has a hidden COVID-19 crisis of food

Commentary: India has a hidden COVID-19 crisis of food

With the pandemic inducing lockdowns and affecting migration patterns, food security is the unexpected collateral damage, says NUS’ Vani Swarupa Murali.

India Daily Life
Indian farmers sell vegetables at a wholesale vegetable market on the outskirts of Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh, India, Thursday, June 3, 2021. (AP Photo/Rajesh Kumar Singh)

SINGAPORE: India’s second wave of COVID-19 has been brutal on its people.

During the first wave, images emerged of a mass exodus from the major cities with countless people walking – sometimes more than 700 kilometres – back to their villages, many not surviving the journey.

Now it is happening again. The pandemic has also seen increased mortality rates, loss of livelihoods and growing malnutrition.

While some studies have shown the effect of the pandemic on food security in terms of food shortages, rations and government public distribution schemes, not many have looked at the effect it has had on the producers and production of food.

FOOD SHORTAGES

The many quarantine regulations, social distancing rules, lockdowns and border controls have disrupted the supply chain of food and made food security a question mark for many, especially the poor.

Despite the Indian government’s promise to double farmers’ income by 2022, producers have faced one difficulty after another in the last few years.

In late 2018, amid a spike in farmer suicides, growers took to the streets to demand loan waivers and higher prices for their produce in an effort to tackle mounting debt.

The plight of farmers is a major political issue in India with thousands committing suicide in
The plight of farmers is a major political issue in India with thousands committing suicide in recent years due to debt and increasingly erratic weather patterns blamed on climate change. (Photo: AFP/Sajjad HUSSAIN)

In 2020, with scope for record harvests in rice and wheat, farmers appeared optimistic about their year.

This optimism was quickly dampened when the Modi government introduced three new farm acts, which led to protests that continued into 2021.

Farmers congregated in Delhi, the national capital, to object to the takeover of the agricultural sector by big corporates – yet have little to show for their demonstrations.

DIFFICULTIES FOR FARMERS

Ever since the first lockdown in India, producers have faced serious difficulties in maintaining their livelihoods.

A study conducted in May 2020 among almost 1500 farmers revealed that of the 11 per cent who did not harvest their crop, 24 per cent cited lockdown-related reasons.

Of the 63 per cent of farmers who were able to harvest in the month prior to the survey, 39 per cent had stored their crop, with half citing lockdown issues as the reason.

Another survey reported that 15 per cent of farmers were unable to sell their harvest due to lockdowns.

THE EFFECTS OF MIGRATION

These issues are, in part, the result of one of the first consequences of the pandemic: The change in migration patterns.

Virus Outbreak India
Migrant laborers from other states awaiting to be hired for the day gather on a street during a lockdown to curb the spread of coronavirus on the outskirts of Jammu, India, Monday, May 31, 2021. (AP Photo/Channi Anand)

As migrant workers lost their jobs in the cities and returned to their villages, families faced the added pressure of having more mouths to feed.

Most migrants were quick to enter the local labour force as a way to contribute to their family’s income.

The increased demand for jobs and the willingness to work for lower pay depressed overall wage rates and may ultimately affect the viability and productivity of agriculture as a profession in India.

READ: Commentary: Survivors of India’s ferocious second COVID-19 wave left scarred by crisis

READ: Commentary: Grassroots health surveillance can help detect new outbreaks of COVID-19 and other illnesses

The availability of more able-bodied men may also sideline women who are working in agriculture, rejigging gender dynamics.

Some migrants are also seasonal and are expected to return to their villages for rice-sowing season.

However, many of them were stranded in cities during the lockdown. This limited their movement and led to labour shortages in their home villages.

In some cases, states such as Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh – who are reliant on farm labourers from the eastern parts of India, such as Odisha and Jharkhand for harvests – suffered labour shortages and potentially lower yields and profits during the lockdown.

THE IMPACT ON FOOD SECURITY

Given that these areas are considered “breadbasket states” due to the crops they produce, their underproductivity has serious implications for food security around the country.

India Farmers Protests Thirsty Crops
Workers spray pesticide on wheat crop in Ranish Kalan village in Moga district of Indian state of Punjab on Mar 13, 2021. (Photo: AP/Manish Swarup)

Even if the region’s farmers managed to harvest on their own, they then faced the problem of transportation. The halt on transportation services during lockdown meant limited access to the fertilisers, pesticides and seeds that are crucial during the sowing and pre-harvest period.

If they managed to yield a good harvest, taking their produce to the market was nearly impossible with limited transport options available.

The road closures and restrictions on interstate travel impeded the movement of produce across the country and limited the number of sale points.

As a result, there was extreme wastage of perishable commodities such as milk, fruit and vegetables, and a significant number of distress sales.

READ: Commentary: India’s COVID-19 crisis could cause long-lasting economic scars

READ: Commentary: India’s second COVID-19 wave threatens global supplies of vaccines

Those farmers who spent on transportation were left with reduced income to purchase seeds and fertilisers for the next sowing season.

Many of these issues were listed in the May 2020 survey as reasons why 55 per cent of farmers said that the lockdown affected their preparations for the sowing season.

However, rather than focusing on cyclical problems or downward spirals, recent reports suggest that things might be looking up.

With many migrant workers returning to their villages and spending time on farming, the farming sector is seeing “good progress and with good monsoon … a bumper crop and good income”.

Some are even reporting a better quality of life: “City life takes away a lot – health, happiness and community sentiment, though I returned under compulsion, at the moment I am not regretting”.

Perhaps increased help on the farm and a projected good monsoon might be a “silver lining for those who returned home”.

Vani Swarupa Murali is a PhD student at the South Asian Studies department at the National University of Singapore (NUS). She focusses on domestic politics in India and looks specifically into rural India. This commentary first appeared on Lowy Institute's blog The Interpreter. Read it here.

Source: CNA/ml

Bookmark