Commentary: The progressive Indonesian leader set to make waves at the World Bank

Commentary: The progressive Indonesian leader set to make waves at the World Bank

Besides being a win for Asia and Indonesia, Mari Pangestu brings a practical bent and development experience that will support the Bank’s extensive work, says Peter McCawley.

Mari Pangestu
Mari Pangestu speaking at the Hadi Soesastro Policy Forum in 2013 organised by the CSIS and the ANU. Photo credit: Facebook page of CSIS Indonesia. 

CANBERRA: The news that Mari Pangestu, one of Indonesia’s leading economists and policy makers, will be appointed as a Managing Director in the World Bank is a boost for the multilateral system. 

The appointment is a good one for Indonesia, for the Asian region, and for the World Bank.

Pangestu has had a remarkable career as an economic adviser and policy maker in Indonesia. She is well-known internationally, across Asia, in North America, and in Australia as well.

In her early years, Pangestu attended primary school in Canberra. At the time her father, Indonesian academic and banker Professor Panglaykim, was working on research projects at the Australian National University (ANU).

ECONOMIC CAREER

She later returned to the ANU to study for a bachelor’s degree, and then a master’s degree in economics. She went on to the United States for doctoral studies with a focus on international trade. In 1986, Pangestu became the first female Indonesian to graduate with a PhD in economics from the University of California, Davis.

READ: Commentary: Why economists are terrible at predicting the state of the economy

During the next 10 years, Pangestu moved into a leading position in Indonesia’s most well-known think-tank, the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Jakarta. 

CSIS was a hive of activity in Indonesia and overseas sponsoring dozens of international conferences to discuss Asian regional affairs and the need to support economic reform across the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) members.

Pangestu and her CSIS economic colleagues played a unique role in pressing for liberalisation within Indonesia. They became the focal point for Indonesia’s involvement in the Pacific Economic Cooperation Council (PECC) which prepared studies on topics for multilateral and regional trade reform.

The CSIS team was active in promoting Indonesia’s involvement in the Asian Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum.

In 1997, Pangestu was appointed Executive Director of CSIS just as the Asian financial crisis was unfolding across South East Asia. Indonesia was hard-hit by the crisis.

The rupiah has slumped to its lowest point against the dollar since the Asian financial crisis
The Indonesian rupiah and economy was hard-hit by the Asian financial crisis. (Photo: AFP/Bay Ismoyo)

An immediate challenge for CSIS, which Pangestu needed to manage, was to restructure the work of the organisation and reach out to new partners.

READ: Commentary: The end of the decade – the world is in more debt and it isn’t going away

POLITICAL CAREER

In 2004, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono was elected President of Indonesia.

It was clear that Yudhoyono was keen to select a progressive cabinet of ministers with professional qualifications. Indeed, just a few weeks before he became President, Yudhoyono completed his own doctoral degree in economics from the Agricultural University in Bogor near Jakarta.

READ: Commentary: What Nadiem Makarim brings to the table as education and culture minister

One of the professional women he appointed to the cabinet was economist Sri Mulyani Indrawati who later, in 2010, became Managing Director of the World Bank. And another professional woman he appointed was Pangestu who became Minister for Trade.

READ: Commentary: Indonesia’s high-stakes stand-off with China in the South China Sea

The job of Minister for Trade in Indonesia is a difficult one. The portfolio has wide responsibilities which include regulation of key domestic markets as well as managing international trade issues. Pangestu was widely regarded as a highly effective minister who handled the portfolio with skill.

In recognition of her role in government in Indonesia, in 2013 she was awarded an honorary degree by the ANU.

BANKING ON HER EXPERIENCE

Against this background, as a new Managing Director, Pangestu brings three key insights to the World Bank.

First, her own experience of the practical challenges of day-to-day policy-making on the ground will hopefully keep some of the loftier World Bank pronouncements about international issues grounded in reality. 

As a minister with responsibilities for tourism she famously pointed to the need for better toilets for tourists in Indonesia. An emphasis on this practical approach will be welcome in the Word Bank’s programs in developing countries.

Second, Pangestu will bring to the Bank a vital understanding of the importance of openness – of the need for developing countries to remain as open as possible to the global economy.

Indonesia slum
A slum in Indonesia. East Asia and the Pacific are still home to the world's biggest population of slum dwellers at 250 million, the World Bank said in a 2017 report. (Photo: AFP)

It is true that openness is a two-edged sword. Openness and globalisation bring challenges as well as benefits.

It is no secret that Pangestu had to deal with both edges of the sword in her seven years as Trade Minister in Indonesia. But Indonesia has benefited greatly from being a relatively open economy in recent decades. 

READ: Commentary: The brewing discontent with trade and one step to restoring faith in globalisation

Pangestu will hopefully be able to share Indonesia’s experience across the Bank.

LEVERAGING INDONESIA'S LESSONS

A third insight that Pangestu will bring to the Bank is a knowledge of the impact of the remarkable long-term development programme that the international community has supported in Indonesia.

READ: Commentary: Jakarta, the fastest sinking city in the world faces the biggest flooding challenge

Pangestu recently prepared a study of the economic history of Indonesia during this period in a collection of articles about the work of Ali Wardhana, Indonesia’s longest-serving finance minister.

In the 50-year period from the late 1960s to 2016, the international community provided around US$340 billion in support to Indonesia. The World Bank itself played a key role in this programme, supporting financial flows and – more importantly – helping coordinate the international effort for five decades.

The international effort began in May 1968 when the former US Secretary of Defence, Robert McNamara, visited Indonesia.

McNamara had just taken up the post of President of the World Bank. His very first international tour as Bank President was to Indonesia. There are extensive details of his visit in the World Bank archives.

Pangestu will be able to draw on this history of one the World Bank’s most successful programmes as she takes up her position as one of the Managing Directors of the Bank.

Peter McCawley is a Visiting Fellow in the Arndt-Corden Department of Economics at the Australian National University (ANU). This commentary first appeared on Lowy Institute's blog The Interpreter. Read it here.

Source: CNA/ml(sl)

Bookmark