Commentary: North Korea may have benefited from the pandemic after all

Commentary: North Korea may have benefited from the pandemic after all

With Washington distracted by COVID-19, the crisis allowed Beijing to cooperate with Pyongyang without usual censure, says a Korea politics observer.

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un visits the Samchon Catfish Farm
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un visits the Samchon Catfish Farm, in this undated photo released by North Korea's Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) in Pyongyang on February 21, 2017. (Photo: KCNA/Handout via Reuters)

SYDNEY: Recent news reports about North Korea reopening its schools and easing its restrictions on border trade with China after more than four months of coronavirus-related closure indicate that normalcy is returning to the hermit kingdom.

While it would be far-fetched to fairly evaluate Pyongyang’s response to the pandemic due to a lack of credible statistics on the number of infections, experts generally agree that North Korea has succeeded in controlling the virus.

North Korea is a poor country, but when it comes to pandemic control, time may be more important than resources. Cheap measures such as heavy-handed contact tracing and quarantine can prevent community spread and ease the burden on the decrepit healthcare infrastructure.

As the dust settles, it is important to assess whether North Korea gains or loses from the pandemic. Did the pandemic put North Korea in a more advantageous position compared to the negotiation deadlock in the latter half of 2019? And can Pyongyang exploit the pandemic to further its ends?

LIFE HAS BEEN HARDER FOR NORTH KOREANS

North Korea may have economically suffered, but its time-buying strategy has received a boost thanks to the pandemic.

China and South Korea’s support for North Korea during times of hardship, and the neglect of the North Korea issue by the United States are what Pyongyang needs to consolidate its gains after two years of charm offensive.

READ: Commentary: Right now, it must feel good to be Kim Jong Un

READ: Commentary: How is North Korea laundering money – and getting away with it?

The pandemic indeed has made life much harder not only for ordinary North Koreans but also for the central government. The country’s decision to close the border with China has done more damage to its economy than international sanctions.

North Korea’s exports to China in March fell 96 per cent compared to March 2019 to just US$616,000, according to one report.

In this file photo taken on May 14, 2019, a man looks at shipping containers at a terminal in Hong
In this file photo taken on May 14, 2019, a man looks at shipping containers at a terminal in Hong Kong --the US Treasury has slapped penalties on Taiwan and Hong Kong-based shipping firms said to help North Korea circumvent UN sanctions. (Photo: AFP/Philip FONG)

Pyongyang residents experienced a shortage of foreign consumer goods and a huge increase in prices of food and household appliances.

Moreover, the country’s infant tourism industry faced delay and an uncertain future, as North Korea cannot count on foreign tourists to revive its economy when a Covid-19 vaccine is still unavailable. The economy is so dire that Pyongyang has issued government bonds and resorted to coercion to shore up state finances.

However, North Korea’s temporary economic fall can be offset by luring financial support from China and South Korea.

CHINA’S AID TO NORTH KOREA

China’s dilemma in international sanctions on North Korea is a fear that strict enforcement could lead North Korea to collapse.

The pandemic allowed Beijing to cooperate with Pyongyang to help fight COVID-19 and “provide assistance” to the country without the negativity associated with breaking sanctions.

READ: Commentary: The man who took the biggest bet on North Korea leader Kim Jong Un

READ: Commentary: COVID-19 is stressing North Korea out

China has been vocal about lifting sanctions on North Korea on the grounds that such measures hurt ordinary North Koreans. North Korea and China have also been preparing to expand cross-border exchange as pandemic border control eases.

SOUTH KOREA HAS BEEN HELPFUL

South Korea is also interested in sanctions relief for the North and North-South healthcare cooperation.

As South Korea President Moon Jae-in no longer faces any electoral battles until the end of his term, Moon may strongly push for inter-Korean exchanges independently of the United States and lay the groundwork for his successor to continue the détente.

For instance, Seoul can call for the reopening of the Kaesong Industrial Complex to produce facemasks and personal protection equipment.

READ: Commentary: North Korea has been trolling us all this while

North Korean laborers work in 2007 at a shoe factory in the inter-Korean industrial park of Kaesong,
North Korean labourers work in 2007 at a shoe factory in the inter-Korean industrial park of Kaesong, which South Korea later shut down after rising tension with the North. (Photo: AFP/Lee Jin-man)

Cross-border railway reconnection projects can also be an area of cooperation, for Seoul can send humanitarian assistance to the North via ground transportation and make a stronger case to bypass the United Nations Command, which controls the inter-Korean border and has dictated the pace of Moon’s peace initiatives.

MEANWHILE, NORTH KOREA HAS FOCUSED ON DEVELOPING MISSILES

On the military front, North Korea did not let the pandemic slow its missile progress and used the time to develop its nuclear capability.

In March, North Korea conducted four short-range missile tests, one more than the first quarter of 2017 before an improvement in inter-Korean and North Korea-United States relations.

A report of the country’s Worker’s Party Plenary meeting in January 2020 hinted at a “new strategic weapon”, which could denote solid-fuel intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM) or a submarine-launched ballistic missile. .

North Korea chairman Kim Jong Un’s recent vow to increase the “nuclear war deterrence” at a Central Military Commission meeting affirms North Korea’s determination to hold on to and expand its nuclear arsenal despite economic hardship.

READ: Commentary: Denuclearising North Korea won't make it a normal country

READ: Commentary: The year Kim Jong Un made his diplomatic debut

In the months after the second summit between Kim and US President Donald Trump in Hanoi, North Korea intentionally avoided talking to the United States in order to extract concessions from Washington.

North Korea’s hardline strategy was based on its time advantage, in which a delay in nuclear negotiation and an arms control agreement only increases the country’s quantity and quality of its nuclear and missile programs. Despite the strong rhetoric in 2019, Pyongyang left the negotiation track open in 2020.

Unfortunately, the poor handling of the pandemic in the US distracts Washington from nuclear negotiations, and so long as Pyongyang refrains from breaking the moratorium on nuclear and ICBM tests, it is not likely that a breakthrough will be made in the second half of 2020.

The pandemic may have delayed North Korea’s economic objectives and posed financial hardship for the government, but the pandemic gives more weight to sanctions relief and buys it more time to advance its strategic weapons.

Pyongyang’s charm offensive has regained China’s support, energised Moon’s push for joint economic exchanges, and stifled the US maximum pressure campaign.

Pyongyang has found a silver lining in the pandemic.

LISTEN: TraceTogether token and contact tracing apps: Privacy, data usage and other big questions

BOOKMARK THIS: Our comprehensive coverage of the coronavirus outbreak and its developments

Download our app or subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on the coronavirus outbreak: https://cna.asia/telegram

Khang Vu is a doctoral student in the Political Science Department at Boston College, where he focuses on East Asian politics and nuclear weapons. This commentary first appeared on Lowy Institute's blog The Interpreter.

Bookmark