Commentary: Where is the line between getting help on a school assignment and cheating?

Commentary: Where is the line between getting help on a school assignment and cheating?

Students and teachers have different ideas of what construes academic misconduct, says Victoria University's Peter Hurley.

FILE PHOTO: Students attend a lecture in an auditorium of a university in Munich
Students attend a lecture in the auditorium of a university in Munich, Germany, May 25, 2016. (Photo: REUTERS/Michaela Rehle/File Photo)

MELBOURNE: Students – whether at university or school – can get help from many places. They can go to a tutor, parent, teacher, a friend or consult a textbook.

But at which point does getting help cross the line into cheating?

Sometimes it’s clear. If you use a spy camera or smartwatch in an exam, you’re clearly cheating. And you’re cheating if you get a friend to sit an exam for you or write your assignment.

At other times the line is blurry. When it’s crossed, it constitutes academic misconduct. Academic misconduct is any action or attempted action that may result in creating an unfair academic advantage for yourself or others.

Could 2017 be smartwatches' turn to be a hit with the general public after years being seen as
A smart watch. (Photo: AFP/Drew Angerer)

READ: Tuition teacher gets jail for helping China students cheat in 2016 O-Level exams

What about getting someone else to read a draft of your essay? What if they do more than proof-read and they alter sections of an assignment? Does that constitute academic misconduct?

LEARNING, TEACHING OR CHEATING? 

There are a wide range of activities that constitute academic misconduct. These can include fabrication, falsification, misrepresentation, and plagiarism. 

Fabrication is just making things up. I could say “90 per cent of people admit to fabricating their assignments,” when this is not a fact but a statement I just invented.

Falsification is manipulating data to inaccurately portray results. This can occur by taking research results out of context and drawing conclusions not supported by data. 

Misrepresentation is falsely representing yourself. Did you know I have a master’s degree from the University of Oxford on this topic? (Actually, I don’t.)

And plagiarism is when you use other people’s ideas or words without appropriate attribution. For instance, this list came from other people’s research and it is important to reference the source.

What you need to know about Career Mobility
(Photo: Unsplash/neonbrand)

Sometimes students and teachers have different ideas of academic misconduct. 

One study found around 45 per cent of academics thought getting someone else to correct a draft could constitute academic misconduct. But only 32 per cent of students thought the same thing.

In the same survey, most academics and students agreed having someone else like a parent or friend identify errors in a draft assignment, as opposed to correcting them, was fine.

Generally, when a lecturer, teacher or another marker is assessing an assignment they need to establish the authenticity of the work. 

Authenticity means having confidence the work actually relates to the performance of the person being assessed, and not of another person.

The Australian government’s vocational education and training sector’s quality watchdog, for instance, considers authenticity as one of four so-called rules of evidence for an “effective assessment”.

Authenticity is where the assessor is confident the evidence presented for assessment is the learner’s own work.

Generally speaking, if the assessor is confident the work is the product of a student’s thoughts and where help has been provided there is proper acknowledgement, it should be fine.

Students studying at a library in Zhengzhou University
FILE PHOTO: Students study ahead of the entrance exam for postgraduate studies, at a library in Zhengzhou University in Zhengzhou, Henan province, China December 13, 2017. (Photo: REUTERS/Stringer)

WHY IS CHEATING A PROBLEM? 

It’s difficult to get a handle on how big the cheating problem is. 

Nearly 30 per cent of students who responded to a 2012 UK survey agreed they had “submitted work taken wholly from an internet source” as their own.

In Australia, 6 per cent of students in a survey of 14,000 reported they had engaged in “outsourcing behaviours” such as submitting someone else’s assignment as their own, and 15 per cent of students had bought, sold or traded notes.

Getting someone to help with your assignment might seem harmless but it can hinder the learning process. The teacher needs to understand where the student is at with their learning, and too much help from others can get in the way.

Some research describes formal education as a type of “signal”. This means educational attainment communicates important information about an individual to a third party such as an employer, a customer, or to an authority like a licensing body or government department. Academic misconduct interferes with that process.

HOW TO DEAL WITH CHEATING

It appears fewer cheaters are getting away with it than before. Some of the world’s leading academic institutions have reported a 40 per cent increase in academic misconduct cases over a three-year period.

Technological advances mean online essay mills and “contract cheating” have become a bigger problem. This type of cheating involves outsourcing work to third parties and is concerning because it is difficult to detect.

ghostwriting 1
Singapore-based ghostwriting services are available a dime a dozen on Carousell. (Photo: Howard Law)

READ: Buying your way to a degree - Singapore-based ghostwriting services target students online

But while technology has made cheating easier, it has also offered sophisticated systems for educators to verify the work is a person’s own. Software programmes such as Turnitin can check if a student has plagiarised their assignment.

Institutions can also verify the evidence they are assessing relates to a student’s actual performance by using a range of assessment methods such as exams, oral presentations, and group assignments.

Academic misconduct can be a learning and cultural issue. 

Many students, particularly when they are new to higher education, are simply not aware what constitutes academic misconduct. Students can often be under enormous pressure that leads them to make poor decisions.

READ: This Asian obsession with Ivy League schools has got to stop, a commentary

It is possible to deal with these issues in a constructive manner that help students learn and get the support they need. 

This can include providing training to students when they first enrol, offering support to assist students who may struggle, and when academic misconduct does occur, taking appropriate steps to ensure it does not happen again.

Peter Hurley is a Policy Fellow at Mitchell Institute, Victoria University. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation. 


Source: CNA/nr(sl)

Bookmark