Commentary: Will killing Islamic State leader Baghdadi give Trump a boost in the polls?

Commentary: Will killing Islamic State leader Baghdadi give Trump a boost in the polls?

Some believe that presidents can boost their approval ratings by waging wars abroad, but such boosts are often short-lived, says LaGrange College's John A Tures.

President Donald Trump makes a statement following reports that U.S. forces attacked Islamic State
US President Donald Trump makes a statement at the White House  in Washington, U.S., on Oct 27, 2019. (Photo: REUTERS/Jim Bourg)

LAGRANGE, Georgia: After former Islamic State group leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi was killed in a US military operation, speculation began on whether President Donald Trump would get a boost in public opinion surveys as a result.

My political science research with my students shows that presidents do enjoy a short-term poll boost after foreign policy raids and capital city captures.

However, that is often followed by a long-term decline.

A CLOSER LOOK AT THE POLLS

Supporters of the diversionary theory of war, known in the media as the “Wag the Dog” effect, contend that presidents can boost their approval ratings in the polls by fighting a war abroad.

In other words, they benefit from a burst of patriotism during the conflict.

READ: Commentary: Islamic State chief Baghdadi’s death exposes its vulnerabilities

But international relations scholars Bradley Lian and John R Oneal tested this theory by looking at conflicts from 1950 to 1984 and found scant empirical support for this hypothesis.

My students and I considered 12 cases to determine whether presidents benefit at the polls from conducting raids involving the capture of a leader, seizure of a capital city or an attempt to rescue hostages, and how long that support can be expected to last.

Ruins near the northwestern Syrian village of Barisha after a US helicopter-borne assault that ended
Ruins near the northwestern Syrian village of Barisha after a US helicopter-borne assault that ended in the death of the leader of Islamic State, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. (Photo: AFP/Omar Hah Kadour)

The events we looked at included the surrender of Manuel Noriega in January of 1990; the apprehension of Saddam Hussein in 2003; and the killing of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011.

We looked at polls conducted by the Gallup Polling Presidential Job Approval Center, calculating an average of three presidential approval polls taken before the foreign policy event, and the mean of the first three polls issued after the case.

Read: Commentary: Trump's latest foreign policy moves undermine US allies' confidence

We also analysed polls taken by the end of the year, or six months later if the raid took place near the end of the year, to see how presidents fared long after the event.

SHORT-LIVED POPULARITY BOOSTS

Our results show that in 75 per cent of cases, the US president received a boost in the polls shortly after a foreign policy raid or capital capture.

But the jump is short-lived. In 83 per cent of cases, presidential approval declined over the next several months. In seven cases, it fell by more than five percentage points from the initial poll boost.

Read: Commentary: Trump’s impeachment highly likely but don’t hold breath (yet) for conviction or removal

For example, President Donald Trump insisted that al-Baghdadi’s death was a bigger deal than the raid that killed Osama Bin Laden. That May 2011 event was widely credited with sealing President Barack Obama’s re-election the following year.

Obama in White House Situation Room
President Obama and Vice President Joe Biden, along with members of the national security team, receive an update on the mission against Osama bin Laden in the Situation Room of the White House, May 1, 2011. REUTERS/White House/Pete Souza

That credit may have been misplaced. Our evidence shows that Obama’s approval ratings had declined to 45 per cent by December of 2011.

Thus, if history is any guide, I expect that Trump may have higher approval ratings in the coming days but shouldn’t count on better polls over the next several months.

John A Tures is a professor of political science at LaGrange College. This piece first appeared in The Conversation.

Source: CNA/el(sl)

Bookmark