Commentary: How do you ensure social distancing when evacuating people from a hurricane?

Commentary: How do you ensure social distancing when evacuating people from a hurricane?

The steps people take to prepare for a severe storm or to evacuate can contradict public health recommendations for protecting themselves and others from COVID-19, says an observer.

New Orleans prepares for Hurricane Laura
A woman puts sandbags on a cart as Hurricane Laura warnings were issued for part of Louisiana and Texas, in New Orleans, Louisiana, US, Aug 25, 2020. (Photo: REUTERS/Kathleen Flynn)

COLLEGE STATION, Texas: With the Hurricane Laura hitting Louisiana and Texas as an “extremely dangerous” Category 4 storm and wildfires menacing the western US, millions of Americans are facing the complex risks of a natural disaster striking in the middle of a pandemic.

The steps people normally take to prepare for a severe storm or to evacuate can contradict the public health recommendations for protecting themselves and others from COVID-19.

That’s what millions of people were facing as Hurricane Laura intensified in the Gulf of Mexico. More than half a million people were under evacuation orders, including the cities Galveston, Beaumont and Port Arthur, Texas.

READ: Trump tours Louisiana city hit by Hurricane Laura, says state 'rebuilds fast'

My urban resilience lab at Texas A&M University has been examining interactions between urban infrastructure, systems and people in disasters.

At the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, we launched a study into the effect of the pandemic on urban systems during a natural disaster, applying similar methods we used during extensive research on Hurricane Harvey, which flooded Houston in August 2017.

Our research shows that compound disasters have complex ramifications. At the intersection of a natural hazard and a pandemic is a decision process fraught with contradictions.

READ: Commentary: Making sense of shifting goalposts in public policy and the science of COVID-19

STORM PREP AND EVACUATION RAISE THE RISKS

During the three days before Hurricane Harvey hit, the number of grocery store and gas station visits in the Houston area increased by 50 per cent to 100 per cent. People didn’t think twice about running to the store.

As Hurricane Laura headed for the Louisiana and Texas coasts, residents were in very a different situation. The rise of COVID-19 illnesses and deaths across the South during the summer meant people were encouraged to self-quarantine and limit their social contact to prevent transmitting the coronavirus.

People prepare to board a bus in Lake Charles, Louisiana for evacuation before the arrival of
People prepare to board a bus in Lake Charles, Louisiana for evacuation before the arrival of Hurricane Laura AFP/Andrew CABALLERO-REYNOLDS

They could still wear masks in stores, but keeping the recommended six feet apart gets harder when stores get crowded. It means spending more time waiting with others in lines and jostling in the aisles.

Research shows that both the amount of virus and the amount of time a person is exposed to it have an impact on whether they get infected and how severely.

READ: Commentary: The US was just not built to handle COVID-19

An even more onerous complication – for both authorities and residents – is evacuation.

The decision to evacuate in the face of even a single hazard, whether a wildfire or a hurricane, is difficult. Sheltering in place can mean life-threatening conditions, prolonged power outages and disrupted access to critical facilities. Evacuating means leaving behind one’s house and possibly animals to an uncertain fate.

That’s complicated further when an emergency shelter is the best choice, but staying in one can mean a higher risk of being exposed to someone infected with the coronavirus.

READ: Commentary: The wonder of clear skies and returning wildlife is our new climate problem

WHICH AREAS ARE MOST VULNERABLE?

Authorities assess many variables when deciding between mandatory and voluntary evacuations. In the face of a pandemic, they now also have to think about disease transmission – and not just in individual emergency shelters but also on a larger scale.

When a large population moves from an area with a high rate of disease spread to a less affected area, it can put the local population at higher risk.

Using data on social vulnerability, pandemic risk and hazard probability, my lab created an interactive map that pinpoints sources of vulnerability. The goal is to enable disaster response managers and decision makers to recognise the compound risks posed by the confluence of the pandemic and any natural hazard.

hurricane
Texas A&M’s compound risk map shows how high rates of COVID-19 and poverty increase vulnerability. The lightest colored counties and parishes face the highest compound risks. The index accounts for hurricane and flood risk, COVID-19 spread, and socioeconomic and other vulnerabilities. (Graphic: Texas A&M UrbanResilience AI Lab)

The compound hazard risk index takes into consideration the social, physical and pandemic risks at the local level, enabling each county or community to make informed decisions. It also raises warnings about vulnerable groups, such as the elderly and low-income communities, which may suffer a disproportionate risk of infection.

We found several counties with significantly high levels of compound risks.

For example, Harris County, Texas, home to Houston, has a large number of COVID-19 cases and is also vulnerable to the impacts of hurricanes. When a hurricane heads for the region, the index can help raise red flags, particularly for local health officials and hospitals, about the risks of exacerbating the pandemic there and in counties where people may go in an evacuation.

Conversely, a county with low hurricane and flooding risks might normally be seen as a suitable location for evacuation, but if it has a high rate of COVID-19, that raises the risk for evacuees who would need to spend time in shelters, hotels, restaurants and stores.

READ: Commentary: Rising temperatures, fires and floods highlight importance of understanding weather extremes

READ: Commentary: World’s struggle with coronavirus will affect growth and employment for a long time

Getting healthcare can also become harder during a natural disaster. Hospitals may see an influx of injuries, and wildfires and flooding can block access to critical health care facilities, damage the buildings, cut power to homes and care facilities and shut down pandemic testing locations.

Other researchers have also explored the potential for an evacuation spreading COVID-19.

In a recent study of evacuation patterns and COVID-19 cases in Florida, researchers at the Union of Concerned Scientists estimated that if a Category 3 hurricane hit Southeast Florida, the difference in that region between evacuees taking shelter in communities with low coronavirus transmission rates versus those with high rates could be as high as 50,000 new COVID-19 cases.

As our research shows, preparing for and responding to the compound disaster of a natural hazard in the midst of a pandemic is an undertaking more complicated than the sum of its parts.

BOOKMARK THIS: Our comprehensive coverage of the coronavirus outbreak and its developments

Download our app or subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on the coronavirus outbreak: https://cna.asia/telegram

Ali Mostafavi is Associate Professor of Civil Engineering at Texas A&M University. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation.

Source: CNA/el

Bookmark