Hong Kong lawmakers' resignations a 'challenge' to authority: China

Hong Kong lawmakers' resignations a 'challenge' to authority: China

Pro-democracy lawmaker Claudia Mo holds a yellow umbrella and her resignation letter at the
Pro-democracy lawmaker Claudia Mo holds a yellow umbrella and her resignation letter at the Legislative Council in Hong Kong on Nov 12, 2020. (Photo: AFP/Peter Parks)

HONG KONG: China warned on Thursday (Nov 12) the mass resignations of pro-democracy lawmakers in Hong Kong were a "blatant challenge" to its authority over the city.

The legislators were set to quit the chamber in protest at the Beijing-sanctioned ousting of four colleagues, leaving the assembly a muted gathering of government loyalists.

The resignations come with the city's beleaguered protest movement and avenues of dissent already under sustained attack since Beijing imposed a sweeping national security law this year.

Most of the 15 did not attend a regular session of the legislature on Thursday, and some later handed in resignation letters at the Legislative Council’s secretariat, sparking a furious response from Beijing's Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office.

"It once again showed their stubborn confrontation against the central government and a blatant challenge to the power of the central government. We severely condemn this," a statement said.

"We have to tell these opposition lawmakers, that if they want to use this to advocate a radical fight, and beg for foreign forces to interfere, and once again drag Hong Kong into chaos, that's a wrong calculation."

READ: Hong Kong legislature sits without democrats after exodus

Inside the chamber, government loyalists discussed a transport Bill, but without any of the rambunctious debate that has been the mark of Hong Kong's semi-democracy in recent years.

"Hong Kongers - prepare for a long, long time where there is only one voice in society," pro-democracy lawmaker Lam Cheuk-ting told reporters outside.

"If you are a dissident, get ready for even more pressure."

Hong Kong chief executive Carrie Lam, a Beijing appointee, on Wednesday was granted the power to turf out any legislator who she deems insufficiently patriotic, without recourse to the city's courts.

She immediately made use of those powers, kicking out four lawmakers she said were a threat to national security, and sparking criticism both at home and abroad, with the United States threatening further sanctions on regime figures.

Wu Chi-wai, the head of the pro-democracy bloc, said the Chinese and Hong Kong governments were trying to take away the separation of powers in the city, since the ousting of the four lawmakers bypassed the courts.

“We lost our check-and-balance power, and all the constitutional power in Hong Kong rests in the chief executive's hands,” Wu said.

He said it was the end of the city's "one country, two systems" framework under which Hong Kong has enjoyed autonomy and freedom.

Claudia Mo, a pro-democracy lawmaker who also handed in her resignation, added: "We are quitting the legislature only at this juncture. We're not quitting Hong Kong's democracy fight.”

Chris Patten, the city's last colonial governor, said the move demonstrated Beijing's "total hostility to democratic accountability, and those who wish to stand up for it".

China's foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin rejected the international criticism.

READ: US warns of further China sanctions over Hong Kong moves

Hong Kong's leader is chosen by pro-Beijing committees, but half of its legislature's 70
Hong Kong's leader is chosen by pro-Beijing committees, but half of its legislature's 70 seats are directly elected. (Photo: AFP/Anthony Wallace)

"We urge the relevant people to strictly abide by the basic norms of international law and international relations, stop any form of interference into China's internal affairs, of which Hong Kong affairs are a part," he said.

The exodus of opposition lawmakers neuters one of the last forums for dissent in Hong Kong, as its once-boisterous media reels under a crackdown unleashed by the national security law.

Restrictions on gatherings, partly because of the coronavirus, have also put the lid on the kind of huge rallies that roiled the city last year.

Millions took to the streets in protest over a lack of political accountability and what demonstrators saw as overbearing policing.

Violence and vandalism erupted at some demonstrations, and more than 10,000 people were arrested.

Ivan Choy, senior lecturer at the Chinese University of Hong Kong said pro-Beijing figures would now take advantage of the absence of an opposition in the legislature "to pass many draconian laws".


Hong Kong's leader is chosen by pro-Beijing committees, but half of the legislature's 70 seats are directly elected, offering the city's 7.5 million residents a chance to have their voices heard at the ballot box.

Scuffles and protests would routinely break out in the chamber, with the out-gunned pro-democracy minority often resorting to filibustering and other tactics to try to halt Bills they opposed.

The mass departure will leave Hong Kong’s legislature with just 43 legislators, 41 of whom belong to the pro-Beijing bloc with the remaining two unaligned with either bloc. This means that the legislature could pass Bills favoured by Beijing with little opposition.

READ: Timeline - The impact of the national security law on Hong Kong

Hong Kong legislature graphic

"It seems that the control of Hong Kong has now been exercised by the Chinese Communist Party authority in Beijing," political analyst Willy Lam said, adding the basic rights enshrined when Britain handed the city back to China in 1997 were "seriously jeopardised".

The move by Beijing "has put the final nail in the coffin," Claudia Mo, one of the lawmakers who resigned, told AFP. "It's rule by decree."

"What's the point of going to work every morning thinking 'am I going to be kicked out?'"

Source: Agencies/zl