Commentary: Does Singapore still need a national airline?

Commentary: Does Singapore still need a national airline?

It recently rose in Skytrax rankings to be named second best airline in the world, but Singapore Airlines' performance in the last quarter has sparked a debate on whether the airline is sufficiently innovative.

SIA file photo AFP
A Singapore Airlines plane preparing to take off. (File photo: AFP/Miguel Medina)

SINGAPORE: For the first quarter of 2017, the Singapore Airlines (SIA) Group reported a loss of S$138.3 million. This performance stands in stark contrast to its performance in the financial year from 2015 to 2016, where the SIA Group reported a net profit of S$804 million, and the same quarter in 2016 where the SIA Group reported a net profit of S$225 million.

Admittedly, SIA’s earlier strong performance was largely due to lower net fuel costs, which declined by S$973 million over the previous year. Lower fuel costs were large enough to offset lower passenger flown revenue, and higher staff and aircraft maintenance costs. In addition, the SIA Group's profits were bolstered by strong results from Scoot’s first year of operations and Tiger Airways' performance.

Some people have asked in light of SIA’s recent woes whether a national airline is still a relevant strategy for Singapore today. SIA, together with Cathay Pacific, are the only two airlines in the Asia Pacific that do not have a market of domestic flights to rely on.

My view is that we should cast our eye instead on how much SIA has achieved in restructuring, in order to tackle new markets and compete with other entrants, and assess if these steps have enabled SIA to better position itself to catch headwinds in an evolving global economy.  


Traditionally strong in first- and business-class travel, SIA has been challenged by the rise of North Asian carriers as well as the Gulf carriers, namely, Emirates, Qatar and Etihad, known as the ME3.

Emirates Airlines aircrafts are seen at Dubai International Airport
Emirates Airlines aircraft parked at Dubai International Airport. (File photo: REUTERS/Ashraf Mohammad)

These ME3 carriers have been strongly financed by their respective countries and using SIA’s own strategy, focused on providing new aircraft with superb in-flight entertainment and attention to customer care to grab market share in this lucrative sector. With their long-range aircraft, ME3 carriers are bypassing Singapore’s air hub to transport passengers from Europe and the Middle East through their own air hubs onto other destinations in the Asia Pacific.

In response, SIA has ordered 67 Airbus 350s that are 25 per cent more fuel-efficient to increase their own long-range flights from Singapore to Europe and the US. The cabins of these A350s are also equipped to provide the most comfortable and up-to-date in-flight experience for this premium class of travel, but more importantly, these direct flights save time for business travellers because they do not need a stopover.

These A350s save tremendous operational costs for SIA, eliminating the need for an intermediate stop. Direct flights to the US save SIA an average of more than 30 per cent of operational costs compared to those with stopovers.


In response to the growing competition of budget carriers in the region, SIA has also focused more attention on its own budget carriers, Scoot and Tiger Airways, even merging both airlines to reap potential economies of scale and consolidate its foothold in the budget market. The SIA Group recognises that this is a growing market that is likely to outgrow the premium market where SIA’s growth has remained stagnant or declined over the last few years.

From July 25, Scoot and Tigerair will operate under the Scoot brand and will use a single website,
From Jul 25, Scoot and Tigerair will operate under the Scoot brand and will use a single website, check-in counter and flight designator code. (Photo: AFP/Roslan Rahman)

Looking ahead, SIA has to connect with a whole new generation of younger travellers who have grown up with budget carriers, which entails a reconfiguration of its own business model. The new SIA business model has to accommodate SIA’s premium brand as well as the budget brands of Scoot and Tiger Airways for different range of ticket pricing. However, better coordination and networking among the different carrier brands would enable the SIA group to deliver more competitive pricing and connectivity for its passengers.


In its quest to be adaptable to changing business conditions, SIA is developing its networks and enhancing connectivity by working with various Star Alliance partner airlines on several fronts. Partnerships include joint ventures, code-sharing and even revenue sharing arrangements to reduce costs and ensure continued earnings.

SIA and Ethiopian Airlines recently expanded their code-share agreement to offer passengers seamless connectivity between various destinations across Asia and Africa. SIA also has a wide ranging partnership with Lufthansa to jointly operate major routes between Singapore and Europe.  

The move to integrate SIA Cargo into the SIA group by first half 2018, will help SIA Group take better advantage of passenger aircraft bellyhold space. This enables the cargo division to have more capacity, connectivity and better coordination for cargo space utilisation and delivery. SIA Cargo has also right-sized its fleet downwards to seven 747-400Fs since 2001, a cost-cutting measure that has helped to deal with spare capacity.

In addition, the reintegration of SIA Cargo into the SIA Group would improve efficiency and offer greater flexibility for staff deployment because it would maximize synergies across the grouping. This would position Singapore well as an aviation and cargo logistics hub to take advantage of greater regional economic integration through the ASEAN Economic Community, which is the third largest growth region in Asia, after China and India.

A man walks past a Singapore Airlines signage at Changi Airport in Singapore
A man walks past a Singapore Airlines signage at Changi Airport on May 11, 2016. (Photo: REUTERS/Edgar Su)


Most importantly, SIA has established a transformation office in May 2017 to conduct a wide-ranging review of its entire business strategy and operations. In time, the office will help better position the SIA group for long-term sustainable growth.

A key part of this transformation will be the need to retrain, reskill and redeploy its human capital across its portfolio companies to cater to the changing needs and emerging consumer demands of a new generation of businesses and travellers as well as to mitigate and curtail job losses.

If the various measures mentioned are successfully implemented, SIA is likely to be in a better position to meet various challenges. While meeting bottom lines for SIA is important, and its companies need to be profit generating and have sustainable business models, SIA is also an important pillar supporting Singapore’s ambition to be an aviation hub that would provide a whole slew of services and jobs for the future.

Artist's impression of Jewel Changi Airport, which is slated to open in early 2019. (Image: Changi Airport Group)

The International Air Transport Association has released a study that projects that aviation-related jobs will double in Singapore from 320,000 in 2014 to 700,000 by 2035. The aviation sector's contribution to Singapore's gross domestic product will also more than double from S$42 billion in 2014 to S$88 billion in 2035.

What lies beyond being an air hub? In 2016, about 35 per cent of the value of global trade was transported by aircraft. Cities like Singapore that are close to airports provide companies faster access to suppliers and customers and will be transformed into future “aerotropolis”, according to aviation and urban planning experts John Kasarda and Greg Lindsay. These aerotropolis are designed and custom built for the “economy of speed” in which a premium is placed on transporting valuable goods and human capital efficiently and seamlessly.

SIA has fired a few salvos to transform its business model. We need to give it time for the transformation to come to fruition before judging if Singapore still needs SIA. For the time being, the answer is yes because SIA has moved fast to respond to new challenges. Time will tell if these steps are enough.

Dr Faizal Yahya is a senior research fellow at the Institute of Policy Studies at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy in the National University of Singapore.

Source: CNA/sl