Adjust policies, make use of technology to help workers
While automation will eventually displace many sweatshop workers across Asia, the situation may not be as grim or urgent as it may seem (“Asian workers need to wake up to automation”; Sept 6).
Most sweatshops are not run directly by the foreign firms that rely on their output, but are largely owned and operated by local managers and subcontractors instead.
The foreign clients enjoy most of the profits and cost savings from sweatshop labour, while the contractors face slimmer margins.
Hence, while automation saves money in the long run, many sweatshop operators may not be able to afford the initial cost of conversion.
Moreover, in less-developed countries, labour remains more affordable, available and replaceable than expensive, hard-to-import and difficult-to-repair machines, at least for now.
This suggests that, until automation becomes more normalised, countries dependent on the sweatshop industry have time to adapt by adjusting labour policies and allowing their economies to mature.
One could, in fact, argue that those facing the most immediate risk from automation are white-collar workers in developed nations who perform back-office tedium. There are three main reasons this group is first on the chopping block.
First, these kinds of functions are easily accomplished using inexpensive, off-the-shelf technology. Conversion can be done immediately, rather than having to wait for the technology to mature.
Second, firms stand to reap greater savings by replacing high-wage employees who account for a greater proportion of labour costs than by replacing low-end, low-cost tasks.
Third, the multinational firms employing these sorts of workers can more than afford the capital expenditure on a switchover.
At the same time, the advanced economies, such as Singapore and Hong Kong, most susceptible to this form of automation are the ones best equipped to undertake economic restructuring and corrective policy measures.
Bearing in mind this risk assessment, we should not fear the onset of automation, but instead focus on preparing for the next industrial revolution.