Skip to main content
Advertisement

Voices

Better understanding of China needed

Chong Lee Ming
25 Jun 2015 04:16AM

I refer to the commentary, “China’s rise and the lessons of history” (June 22).

While I agree with the need to question how closely a country’s past and present are linked, and to look at diverse historical examples, the writer did not consider the Chinese perspective on the events he cited.

Firstly, the Manchus, founders of the Qing dynasty, were an aggressive people who conquered China. But like most other conquerors of China before them, they were assimilated and tamed.

Cultural assimilation, not military conquest, was mainly why some of China’s neighbours disappeared. The present government is the legitimate successor to the Qing dynasty, and therefore has rightful claims to Taiwan, Xinjiang and Tibet.

CNA Games
Show More
Show Less

While China’s actions in the other military conflicts with its neighbours might not be considered purely defensive, the irony is that from its perspective, the impetus of war was to force the opposing party to respect international laws.

One should note that it did not retain any territories occupied during these conflicts.

As for the events in the South China Sea, they are not a straightforward indicator of China’s aggression as some would have others believe. The nationalist government made the territorial claims, but Beijing no longer controls a large number of land features there.

The present communist government must demonstrate to its people that it is able to control the remaining land features, so that it will not be seen as weaker than the nationalist government.

At the same time, China has a lot to lose economically if it quarrels with numerous neighbours. Therefore, there are limitations to its potential actions.

Many Western observers are unable to have a balanced perspective on China because they see its government in the following order: Communist, an autocracy, and Chinese.

They might not have noticed that the present leaders quote more from Chinese classical texts than from Karl Marx.

The leaders know that they can no longer maintain legitimacy based on Marxism, and are driving, albeit carefully, a Chinese renaissance to sustain their legitimacy.

Asian observers such as historian Wang Gungwu and former Foreign Affairs Minister George Yeo would probably have noticed this better than most Western observers, and are therefore more confident that China’s resurgence would be peaceful.

Source: TODAY
Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement