Skip to main content
Advertisement

Voices

Big difference between freedom of expression and incitement to hatred

Xavier Nuttin
07 May 2015 04:17AM

In his commentary “Practical, not ideological, approach needed on human rights” (May 1), Ambassador-at-large Bilahari Kausikan repeats what he wrote on Jan 15 after the Charlie Hebdo massacre: “Nothing justifies murder. But is it right to constantly lampoon a religion?”

Failing to condemn unconditionally and unambiguously the use of violence provides grounds for the extremists to continue their hate campaign. The murderers and the victims are not similar; the blame cannot be shared.

Those heinous crimes are unacceptable expressions of intolerance. Nothing can justify killing journalists, regardless of the controversial aspect of a journal’s content or editorial line. No arguments should be used to justify cold-blooded murders done by terrorists.

Mr Kausikan criticised Western policies, particularly European values. But the universality of human rights is not a Western invention: It was first enshrined in the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1948 — not a European Union treaty.

CNA Games
Show More
Show Less

There is also a big difference between freedom of expression and incitement to hatred, a point many seem to be missing. The “practical” approach to human rights, as he advocated, can lead to a reduction of civil and political liberties.

From a European perspective, the right to criticise is the lifeblood of a democratic system. And without freedom of expression and the press, there cannot be informed, active and engaged citizen participation in the political process. That is why press freedom is a pillar of any society. Fundamental rights do not create extremism, hate or tensions between ethnic or religious communities.

It is the extremists, whose aim is to destabilise societies that do not abide by their views, who bear that responsibility. They want to attack the right to live together and in safety, irrespective of different opinions and confessions.

They want to attack freedom and impose their exclusive viewpoint. To be blind to this and hide behind “specific circumstances” or the “context of particular cultures” will not help in making our societies more just and all-inclusive.

Source: TODAY
Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement