Effects of ‘parentocracy’ overrated
It is easy to blame parentocracy for limiting upward social mobility in Singapore today. But its effects are overrated (“Emphasis on paper qualifications worsens consequences of ‘parentocracy’”; Aug 22).
Most would agree that we are all born with different abilities. While education can close the gap, it cannot completely overcome one’s natural limits.
Some of the additional resources parents pour into their children might give them a head start, but the effects would probably taper off later, particularly in post-secondary education when traits such as self-discipline and inquisitiveness are probably more important.
Studies might suggest that the quality of nurturing a person receives in early childhood has a lasting impact, but I doubt there can be a definitive conclusion. It is difficult for studies to isolate the effects of one’s natural ability from many other factors that could have influenced a person’s development.
I believe there could be two other factors — both are still parent-related — in explaining why there is less social mobility in more affluent societies such as Singapore.
First, children whose parents have positive traits such as discipline, hard work and healthy habits are more likely to acquire these traits from their parents. People with such traits are more likely to be successful, creating a virtuous circle.
Many successful people from poorer backgrounds also attribute their success to their parents’ positive influence. Their parents may not be affluent, due to limited opportunities in the past, but had maintained and passed on these values to their children, helping them to be successful as society progresses.
Second, there is some intergenerational correlation in human intelligence. In poor societies, some intelligent people might not have adequate education and job opportunities to develop their potential well. Their children have better opportunities and hence are more successful. As society progresses, there would be fewer such cases and less social mobility is observed.
Our educational system is generally able to provide equal opportunities for all, but we can do more to reduce our reliance on low-cost workers and build up a strong vocational culture, similar to Germany and Japan. Those who are less academically inclined can then make a decent living here, too.