Skip to main content
Advertisement

Voices

Fee guidelines for doctors should be reintroduced

Edmund Khoo KIm Hock
25 Aug 2015 04:16AM

It was suggested that the increase in complaints against doctors points not to a declining standard of care, but to miscommunication between patient and physician (“Doctor-patient ties can improve with better communication”; Aug 21).

Despite patients being more knowledgeable because of the free flow of information and correspondingly higher expectations, patients are never fully informed when interacting with their doctors. Most patients will not challenge recommended laboratory and radiology tests and procedures.

A common complaint against medical practitioners, however, is that of perceived overcharging. Doctors must remind themselves that they interact with patients from a position of advantage. Even the altruistic ones among them plan to accumulate wealth, like any working professional.

Hence, medical students and young doctors must be reminded by their mentors to be guided always by their conscience when managing patients.

CNA Games
Show More
Show Less

Often, a patient gripes about the bill when it is far from what he expected. Doctors must inform patients of what to expect at the various treatment stages, from the cost of diagnostics and procedures to that of the hospital stay.

If there are additional charges owing to complications, doctors should update the patient and his or her family at the earliest opportune time.

When an estimate of the total bill is communicated satisfactorily from the outset and agreed upon by the patient, complaints of overcharging may not ensue in the first place.

There may be cases, however, when the final bill may not escalate from the estimate but still be deemed excessive by the patient or his family.

Disciplinary proceedings seldom commence in marginal cases of perceived overcharging. The few that have gone to the disciplinary committee involved outrageous disregard for ethical limits in billings.

The Singapore Medical Association fee guidelines introduced in 1987 were abandoned after the Competition Commission of Singapore ruled that they were anti-competitive in nature.

Though these guidelines no longer exist, their fee range, deemed fair at that time, should be used as a reference, taking inflation into account.

The Health Ministry seems to be leaning towards greater price transparency by publishing percentile bill sizes for straightforward surgeries in restructured and private hospitals.

Owing to the disparity in professional fees between surgeons in private practice, however, we are still far from knowing clearly what a fair charge for their services is.

There is also no agreement on reasonable fees for cases when complications set in, and the surgeon’s expertise may mean the difference between life and death.

What is clear is that doctors have a high ethical obligation, enshrined in the Hippocratic Oath, which prevails over all other business considerations.

Since the ethical limit for doctors’ fees remains discretionary, fee guidelines for physicians should be reintroduced.

Source: TODAY
Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement