How to sell the TPP
After five years of tortuous negotiations, the United States, Japan and 10 other Pacific Rim countries have reached an agreement on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), one of the most ambitious trade pacts ever attempted. Not everybody is suitably impressed.
Besides several US presidential candidates in both parties, the opposition includes many members of Congress and other national legislatures that must ratify the pact. So now the national leaders who worked so hard to get this deal signed have to be equally persistent in selling it to their respective electorates.
Getting the TPP up and running would be more than a momentary political win for US President Barack Obama and his partners in the talks. Once in place, it will significantly advance living standards across the region and beyond.
The TPP includes plenty of traditional trade-liberalising measures — lower tariffs and non-tariff barriers — but it also applies them to new areas. Trade in agriculture and services will be opened up. New rules acknowledge the digital economy. There will be stronger protection for intellectual property. Restrictions on international investment will be pared back. Labour and environmental standards will be tightened, but in ways that do not discriminate against trade.
In all these ways, the scope of the agreement goes well beyond what has been achieved in previous rounds of global trade liberalisation. It is a shame that such a far-reaching deal could not be done for the world economy as a whole, and that the World Trade Organization’s Doha Round of global talks is struggling to get anywhere. The good news, though, is that the TPP is capable of being scaled up.
At present, China is not a member; in the future, it should be. Beyond the Pacific Rim, the deal can provide a template for liberalisation in other regions. Eventually, merging the TPP with the proposed trade pact between the US and the European Union is not out of the question.
Is all this effort to spur trade really such a good thing? It is. More trade means more competition, which means higher productivity, hence better products and lower prices — in other words, higher living standards. Undeniably, the process is disruptive and not everybody will win. In this respect, trade is akin to technological progress: It is just as challenging and just as indispensable.
In making the case for expanding trade, governments would be wise to stop apologising for economic progress. They should also stop claiming that greater trade “creates jobs”, as though no jobs will be lost as industries shift and restructure. Instead, they should turn their attention to improving opportunities for the minority of workers who will bear the brunt.
It remains to be seen exactly how particular points of controversy were resolved in the final hours of discussion. Numerous compromises had to be struck on questions such as the scope of a new dispute-settlement mechanism, which many have argued would make it too easy for companies to evade national regulation.
The deal exempts the tobacco industry from these protections; producers had been abusing trade rules to undercut restrictions on smoking. Environmental provisions will allow trade penalties to be imposed on countries that fail to protect endangered species. Stronger rules on intellectual property will warrant close examination. In weighing the pact, lawmakers ought to recognise that all such deals involve compromise, and look at the big picture.
The TPP will spur growth across roughly 40 per cent of the world economy. If the US and its partners are looking for a way to counter the growing pessimism about the world’s economy, they can start by putting the TPP into effect as soon as possible. BLOOMBERG