Increase size of fund-raising pie
I refer to the report, “NCSS wants to help charities with weak or no fundraising capabilities” (June 17).
This move by the National Council of Social Service (NCSS) is well-intentioned, especially as 85 per cent of funds raised in 2012 went to large charities with annual receipts of above S$10 million.
In the short term, smaller organisations may benefit from its services. But in the long term, the NCSS should look to increase the size of the fund-raising pie.
Besides that, Singaporeans should be encouraged to donate based on the charities’ effectiveness, the performance results they can show, and the sustainable impact they may have on their beneficiaries.
The number of charities grew from 2,028 in 2010 to 2,142 in 2013, but tax-deductible donations fell to S$970 million in 2013, down 6 per cent from S$1.031 billion in 2012. Quantitatively, the challenge is obvious for all charities.
The “silent sufferers” notwithstanding — those who may not have the same public support — it is not necessarily fair to criticise the fund-raising disparities between small and large charities without considering the number of beneficiaries in each of these organisations.
The quality of assistance can be further evaluated, too. In some sense, the organisation’s growth or size may be evidence of that quality.
Distinctions should also be made between corporate and individual donations. The former can be boosted by strategic planning or consultancy; the same can be done for the latter only if the public is more cognisant of the work done by non-profits.
The NCSS’ undertaking to help smaller charities ramp up their fund-raising capabilities would count for little if the public is not in sync with these efforts.
Before donating, Singaporeans should look more critically at information provided by organisations, taking inspiration, for instance, from American charity evaluator Charity Navigator, which empowers donors to make well-informed decisions along three dimensions.
These are financial health, accountability and transparency, as well as mission-related results. In Singapore, the Charity Portal provides data for the first two dimensions, although more work can be expected for the final one.
Such outreach can start at a young age. Usually, community service in schools is pragmatic, or students complete projects without understanding their motivations or their organisations’ needs. Comparisons can be made across non-profits, based on their target audience and areas of influence.
The eventual intent is for corporates and individuals to contribute larger amounts sustainably and, armed with knowledge of charities here, to make wiser choices, funding the most effective ones in the process.