Learn a third language at home, not school
I refer to the commentary “Picking up a third language can firm up bonds between S’poreans” (June 9).
The proposal for Singaporeans to acquire the mother tongue of another racial group here, so as to “expand our cultural consciousness beyond our individual ethnic groups”, is well-intentioned, although practical thought should be given to its implementation.
The benefits are clear, but what about the costs?
At first glance, schools appear to be the expedient platform for such learning, but considering demographic changes and a growing body of research affirming the importance of pre-school instruction, the home may provide a more conducive platform.
Challenges at school are not limited to manpower and resources. It is unclear whether pupils, stretched by a curriculum often deemed too stressful, can take on another subject, even if — as proposed — a Primary 3 level of proficiency is desired.
More fundamentally, how are pupils coping now with two languages? The Education Ministry may point to trends in grades and pass rates, vis-a-vis curriculum standards, yet these should be squared with students’ experiences.
Are they already conversant in two languages? Are workloads manageable? Upon graduation, how likely are they to retain usage and proficiency? In this vein, the pupils’ perceptions and capacity both matter in decision-making.
What is more plausible is language education at home, considering that one in five marriages in Singapore in 2015 were inter-ethnic, up from 15 per cent in 2005.
Assuming that both parents are fluent in their second language, which cannot be taken for granted, then their children would be exposed to more than two languages.
The Government’s role in this would not be to dictate or compel pupils to take an additional language, but to encourage greater parental involvement by, for example, providing common or subsidised resources.
This approach is more organic, and other parents are more likely to be convinced of the benefits.