Skip to main content
Advertisement

Voices

Marriage equality is a rights issue

Vivian Rene Tan
07 Oct 2016 08:20PM

I refer to the letter “Inequality of marriage should continue” (Oct 4, online). To advocate marriage equality is not about being pro-LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender); it is a rights issue.

The focus is not whether the institution of marriage is equal or unequal, but on the types of legal rights and obligations that come with it, regardless of sexual orientation.

Marriage, as a legally sanctioned contract, enables a state to regulate spousal access to entitlements, protections and responsibilities such as employment benefits, inheritance rules and the ability to buy residential property as a married couple.

Contrary to the writer’s beliefs, marriage does not prohibit homosexuality and polygamy. First, a Muslim man in Singapore is allowed up to four wives at a time if, among other things, he has the financial ability to support them.

CNA Games
Show More
Show Less

Second, homosexuality is a sexual orientation, not a variant of marriage, and cannot be prohibited by the act of marriage per se.

Today, with the primary focus on the child’s welfare, it is archaic to hold on to the idea of the traditional nuclear family, what with adoptions, assisted reproduction and single-parent families.

To place a requirement on having biological parents is to exclude those families, whose ability to provide a normal childhood is not questioned by society and surely not by the writer.

Saying that children are raised best by their biological parents undermines the role of adoptive parents, step-parents and single parents, all of whom have been able to care for a child as any competent parent would.

The writer says that same-sex marriage robs a child of a father or mother. Following his premise, a divorce would produce the same effect or worse, since the marriage and family are essentially severed.

Parties in same-sex marriages and heterosexual marriages perform the same roles for, and have the same commitment to, their children and each other, but are distinguished by gender alone.

In 1996, marital rights were granted to post-operative transgender people who wish to marry a person of the opposite gender. Since then, we have made no progress in terms of attitudes and policies.

The insistence on discouraging same-sex marriage based on traditional or religious beliefs is a product of a rigid society. Is this the future we envision for Singapore as a forward-thinking nation?

Source: TODAY
Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement