Potential pitfalls of recommended EP changes need to be addressed
I am concerned at some of the Constitutional Commission’s recommendations for the Elected Presidency (EP) and their justifications (“Minority representation needed ‘as Presidency symbolises nation’s unity’”; Sept 8).
The commission rebutted the argument that as minority candidates have done well in general elections, they do not need a special provision for presidential polls. I wonder how the commission concluded that voters choose Members of Parliament partly because of the plans of the candidates’ political parties but assess presidential hopefuls purely on their individual merits. Was there a survey that showcased this voting behaviour?
Residents I have interacted with have said they are more discerning when choosing their MP, who would be directly involved in running their town council, while the President is perceived as a symbolic position assisted by the Council of Presidential Advisers (CPA).
Also, few presidential hopefuls would be unencumbered by their previous political affiliations, and a select few may be endorsed by certain political organisations, so it is a fallacy that residents would judge them on individual merits.
The commission also disagreed that its proposed changes will undermine meritocracy. It said this argument “loses much of its force”, as the eligibility criteria will not be lowered.
This is peculiar because meritocracy means selecting the most eligible person available. However, even if a minority candidate meets the criteria, certain segments of society may be prejudiced against him or her.
As some have pointed out, the suggestion of a “reserved election” is risky because it would be a blow to a minority group if no eligible candidate steps forward despite not being represented in the five preceding terms of office. The proposal to increase the CPA’s powers would also heighten concerns about tokenism, as it would appear that the President would largely be a figurehead.
The commission also rebutted the idea that the provision to ensure minority representation may lead to calls for similar provisions for other offices, such as that of the prime minister.
It argued that no other public office is “a symbol of the nation’s unity” as the Presidency is. This is the commission’s perception, however, and not necessarily a reflection of the way Singapore’s minorities envision the different positions.
How probable is it that minority citizens will accept that they should not make such calls simply because other positions will not be perceived chiefly as symbols of national unity?
From my conversations with minority residents, it seems this recent debate has fired up hopes that this is a first step towards equal representation in major public offices.
I hope that Parliament will robustly debate the potential pitfalls and consequences of the recommended changes to the EP.