Quantify outcomes of intervention for at-risk youths
I refer to the report “New Triage System offers ‘targeted intervention for at-risk youths’” (Nov 5).
The new system — with 12 officers who will provide advice and introduce arrested youth to relevant programmes or agencies — looks promising, though the research and outcomes of the intervention should be quantified.
For instance, over the past decade, how many youths up to 19 years of age in Singapore have been arrested and investigated for minor offences?
A six-month pilot of the initiative may have shown “positive results, with 95.7 per cent of 452 cases being diverted from the criminal justice system”, but what are the implications?
How do these numbers compare with numbers in the past, and how was the triage designed in the first place? Information on previous police investigations and types of sentencing would be useful too.
Effectiveness of this thorough assessment is premised upon strong partnerships between stakeholders. In this vein, besides determining whether the 12 officers across six locations will be adequate, the engagement of the non-profit organisations should be ascertained.
What is the network required for the targeted intervention, as well as the information-sharing practices that would be promoted? Against the backdrop of a many-helping-hands approach, agencies may also be involved in different capacities.
The second of the three initiatives — a longitudinal study involving about 3,300 youth offenders and their primary caregivers over a period of 10 years — will be of great value.
Policy recommendations can be designed in response to the structural challenges faced by at-risk youths, while social workers can craft strategies for their beneficiaries. In turn, the performance of the non-profit organisations can be measured and managed in the long term, in terms of how effective their programmes may be for the youths.