Skytrain at Tuas Second Link may ease jams
The Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) issued an advisory on June 21 that traffic flow at the land checkpoints at Woodlands and Tuas is expected to be heavy this long weekend, and travellers can expect delays due to security checks and the spike in traffic during the Hari Raya Puasa holiday.
However, I would say that there is heavy traffic at these checkpoints almost every weekend. The holiday traffic merely exacerbates the bottlenecks that already exist.
I used to drive across to Malaysia over the weekend, and would often get stuck in traffic even before I reached the checkpoint. Sometimes, it would take me more than four hours just to get into Malaysia.
The checkpoints simply could not handle so many vehicles at the borders during peak periods.
So I switched to taking public transport, using the Johor-Baru-bound buses that pass through Tuas Second Link. This took even more time because the bus would be stuck in the traffic jam that snaked towards the Singapore checkpoint. At the Singapore side, all coaches, buses and vans have to pass through a circular route, and the bottleneck builds there.
The vehicles are subjected to security checks, and travellers cannot alight before they reach the checkpoints. The wait can last more than two hours. Across the link bridge, there is only one designated lane for heavy vehicles, but it is always used by cars, and enforcement by the authorities is not always available.
The Woodlands link may be a better option, because travellers can clear the Singapore checkpoint on foot and even walk across the Causeway, if they wish, to get to the Malaysian border. However, this is not an attractive proposition on hot or rainy days.
Innovative solutions may be required, while not compromising security checks and travel safety for those entering and departing from the checkpoints.
Why not have a shuttle train — similar to our Light Rail Transit (LRT) system or skytrain at Changi Airport — that runs non-stop in a loop between both countries’ checkpoints, especially at Tuas Second Link?
Coaches and buses may drop passengers at the checkpoints. After the security checks and customs clearance, commuters may hop onto the shuttle train and board the buses on the other side. This may help reduce the congestion on the roads and give travellers a smoother journey.