SMEs need more than a favourable window to transform
As the global economy is deteriorating, the Manpower Minister’s call for firms to hasten their transformation is timely (“Gear up for good times by transforming now, firms urged”; Feb 4).
This is particularly relevant to local small and medium enterprises (SMEs) struggling with poor productivity, lagging demand and rising costs.
While a slowing economy provides an opportunity for local enterprises to restructure and gear up for the future, there are also other challenges.
First, transformation is not only about incremental change; it is a fundamental retooling of operations models, which even established enterprises have struggled with or failed to transform.
To restructure well, enterprises need transformation talents. Such expertise, which is critical to transforming business and converting labour inputs into productive outputs, is lacking among both SMEs and bigger enterprises.
Second, restructured SMEs may still be too small to compete successfully in the global marketplace owing to a lack of scale and innovation. To overcome these limitations, those SMEs can pool their competencies and resources to become more competitive.
Unfortunately, there is little of a business culture of collaborative strategies here, although the Government has established the Partnerships for Capability Transformation (PACT) scheme to promote collaboration between large organisations and SMEs.
This is also encouraged by business chambers such as the Singapore International Chamber of Commerce (“Better S’pore productivity ‘requires more collaboration between large, small firms’”; Feb 26).
While such initiatives of the Government and business chambers are steps in the right direction, much depends on large and small organisations’ willingness and competence to invest time and resources in forming alliances and consortia to collaborate on projects.
Considering the difficulties and lack of collaborative traditions, especially among SMEs, the PACT scheme should be extended to support management collaboration. There is also a need to build a business culture that is more embracing of collaboration.
While the current slowdown is an opportunity for businesses to transform, it is also a test of Singapore’s resolve to press on with economic restructuring amid uncertain and sluggish growth.
Though some businesses will be affected, it is imperative that cushioning measures to mitigate the effects of the slowdown do not compromise SMEs’ ability to transform themselves for the future.
The slowdown could be short-lived as central bankers and governments inject stimuli to the economy, so the window for business transformation may not be open for long.
To maximise this opportunity, there may be a need to help SMEs more efficiently. While applications for government grants have been simplified, is there a more effective approach, as the preparation and submission by SMEs can be long and tedious?