Skip to main content
Advertisement

Voices

US within its rights to challenge assertive China

Tim Tio
27 Nov 2015 04:15AM

The commentary “Face-off with China could trigger escalation towards military conflicts” (Nov 25) mentions only the United States and China in the South China Sea tension and ignores the other claimant states’ rights and interests.

The writer faults the US for the recent provocation. That the USS Lassen, a guided missile destroyer, sailed past the Spratly Islands, however, was probably a joint decision by the US and claimant states.

A week after the USS Lassen challenged China’s supposed territorial limits, the US Defence Secretary visited the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt with the Malaysian Defence Minister. Why were they on a US aircraft carrier if not to send China a message?

Another example: In June, the US and Indonesia furthered their defence cooperation.

CNA Games
Show More
Show Less

Let us consider these facts: James Shoal, known as Beting Serupai in Malaysia, is 80km northwest of Sarawak — within Malaysia’s continental shelf — and 1,800km from mainland China.

The Philippines’ Palawan Islands are 80km from the province of Palawan. One of the offshore areas claimed by Beijing lies only 79km northwest of Palawan, with the Chinese coast 800km away.

China is exerting its might while trying to make it look like it is claiming its right. The claimant states in South-east Asia are too weak to confront China one-on-one and not cooperating to present a united front, thus weakening their cause.

The commentary reflects China’s use of military and economic might in the South China Sea dispute. Other claimant states welcome the US’ intervention, and the USS Lassen’s sail-by brought them relief.

Fish, oil and bananas play a role in the sovereignty dispute. The Philippines relies on the South China Sea for fish protein for its people. The economies of Indonesia, Brunei and Malaysia partly depend on it for oil and gas.

More than US$5 trillion (S$7 trillion) in global trade passes through the South China Sea yearly. China’s claims affects those interests. It is right for the US to show up, stand up to China and protect vulnerable states.

Source: TODAY
Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement