Will high-speed rail to KL be worthwhile for S’pore?
I agree with Dr Francis Hutchinson’s commentary “Challenges ahead for the KL-S’pore high-speed rail” (April 1). Added to the challenges he outlined is the question of whether the rail makes economic sense for Singapore.
I wonder how Singapore can optimise the benefits of investing in a costly S$20-billion-plus, 350km system.
The distance from Johor to Jurong East is a fraction of that, and an engineer should be able to estimate the maximum achievable speed and total travel time of that leg. How practical will the results be from a cost-benefit perspective?
Coupled with the numerous challenges, especially financial, operational and political, is this project worthwhile for Singapore in terms of committing the time, effort and resources, considering that the project’s footprint is nearly all on Malaysian land?
A better option for Singapore is to have its own dedicated rail link from Jurong East to the Johor station, with a negotiated immigration and customs arrangement for a throughflow of people.
The savings would be better spent on expanding our MRT network further for a car-lite society, especially in the expectation that demands on our Budget revenue and reserves will grow in future.