Improve coordination to help families in transition
The letter “Clarify HDB assistance scheme for second-time applicants” (March 4) highlights the difficulties that divorced or widowed parents face when applying for public housing.
The writer suggested that the Assistance Scheme for Second-Timers could be undersubscribed. As of end 2015, there were 282 applicants — a low figure considering the divorce rate (7,522 in 2015).
The Housing and Development Board website states that those who have disposed of a flat or private property after divorce or demise of the spouse do not qualify.
Yet divorced couples are often ordered by the court to sell their matrimonial flats, and thus typically fall foul of this criterion on the face of it.
This is a strange outcome when the purpose of the scheme is to help divorced and widowed parents with children below 16 years old.
If the intention is to exclude those who hold on to a matrimonial flat for many years after divorce, but not to disqualify those who sell promptly following a court order, this should be made explicit.
Otherwise, the publicly available criteria are confusing and would deter applicants needlessly. This points to a wider difficulty with information about housing rules.
Our research into the barriers to accessing housing faced by single parents showed that many found HDB rules complicated and hard to understand. The HDB website did not always answer their questions.
Some reported that HDB officers did not always offer explanations for why applications failed or alternatives they could try. Even if there are relevant schemes or waivers available for some rules, these options are not always made known to applicants.
For example, in the last three years, about 1,900 applications to waive the income ceiling for rental housing were made, of which 273 were successful.
Yet we found individuals who, in the face of this ceiling, had been told by the HDB to stop work, took lower-paying jobs or scrambled with difficulty to leave their rental flats, instead of seeking a temporary waiver and extension.
Since HDB officers are the most acquainted with the rules and schemes, they are the best placed to proactively explain the options available to applicants, who are already facing the stresses of divorce or death of a spouse.
Currently, because of opacity in the system, single parents rely on help from their Members of Parliament.
This approach is arbitrary, time-consuming and dependent on the applicant’s individual ability to challenge the system and seek the “right” people for help.
To better ensure that single-parent families receive the support they need, we recommend that the Government establish a central unit catering to families transitioning to single-parent households.
Such a unit should co-ordinate policies and services that would meet their needs and reduce reliance on the current approach.