Skip to main content



commentary Commentary

Commentary: Two critical weeks in Australian Victoria state and Melbourne's COVID-19 fight

Previous restrictions in the Australian state of Victoria have not managed to curb the daily number of cases, say observers.

Commentary: Two critical weeks in Australian Victoria state and Melbourne's COVID-19 fight

Response personnel dispose of rubbish outside a public housing tower, reopened the previous night after being locked down in response to an outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), in Melbourne, Australia, July 10, 2020. (Photo: REUTERS/Sandra Sanders)

MELBOURNE: Victoria Premier Daniel Andrews has announced sweeping changes to businesses across metropolitan Melbourne, including closure of retail stores and restrictions on some industries, including construction.

The new constraints came into force from midnight on Wednesday (Aug 5) night.

They come after metropolitan Melbourne moved to Stage 4 restrictions on Sunday, with a nightly curfew and stricter limits on residents’ movement.

Andrews said maintaining Stage 3 restrictions would mean new daily cases plateau at 400 to 500 indefinitely, so the aim of these new stronger restrictions is to drive daily numbers down. 

Given the apparently widespread transmission of the virus at workplaces, the hope is that restrictions on business will help improve the situation.

LISTEN: The COVID-19 vaccine will be the biggest product launch in history. Can we pull it off?

READ: Commentary: South Korea will outperform many developed economies in this coronavirus downturn

We also expect to see the effects of mandatory mask-wearing alongside other measures, to become evident in the case numbers over the coming week, and further reduced numbers from the latest round of lockdown restrictions to become apparent in two weeks’ time. But this will only happen if Australians stick to the rules.


Monday’s restrictions relate to businesses, and will be in place for at least six weeks. The Victorian government has grouped businesses into three categories:

1. Those that can continue full operations on-site, while maintaining COVID-safe practices. This group includes supermarkets, grocers, butchers, bottle shops, post offices, pharmacies, fuel stations and facilities involved in the frontline pandemic response

2. Others that have to operate under new restrictions. This group includes meat processing and construction sites, which will have to observe new limits on staffing levels

3. Some that will cease all on-site activity and move to home or drive-through delivery where possible. This includes non-essential retailers and restaurants.

Andrews assured Melbourne residents that the continued operation of supermarkets and grocers means there is “no need to be buying months’ worth of groceries”. Melbourne residents can also take heart in the fact takeaway coffee is still allowed.

Victoria's State Premier, Daniel Andrews, who announced the latest measures aimed at tackling the spike in COVID-19 cases. (Photo: REUTERS/Luis Ascui)

Construction and meatworks can continue but will look very different. Major government infrastructure projects, such as level crossing removals, will continue but with around 50 per cent fewer on-site personnel.

Large commercial buildings above three storeys need to reduce to the “practical minimum”, operating at no more than 25 per cent staff capacity. Residential building sites can have no more than five people working on-site at any time.

Abbatoir workers will be required to wear full personal protective equipment, including masks, face shields, gloves and gowns. They will also have their temperatures checked and will be regularly tested for COVID-19.

Meat processing facilities will reduce to two-thirds operating capacity. The rules to abattoirs apply statewide, not just in metropolitan Melbourne – a move Andrews said was essential to prevent the industry’s problems with COVID-19 spreading to regional areas.

The retail sector will have to close storefronts. However, these businesses can continue to provide “click-and-collect”, takeaway or delivery services where possible, all of which minimise interactions between people.

READ: Commentary: Wear your mask properly! Uncovering the reasons behind public mask shaming

READ: Commentary: Tourism’s collapse could worsen the economic crisis we face

Hairdressers, education, elective surgery, brothels and strip clubs, legal services, advertising, and food courts will all be required to cease on-site operations.

Andrews has flagged a “permit system” under which certain workers can be granted permission to travel more than 5km from their homes, and to breach curfew. More details will be provided on this later in the week.


The most common method of spread is through close contact, and a lot of transmission of the coronavirus has been occurring in workplaces. This is because, ultimately, workplaces bring people together. Even masks won’t stop the spread if people come very close together.

The new restrictions will reduce the movement of people, reducing the frequency of contact and the contact time between them. They will reduce the risk of transmission in key industries that have had clusters in the past, such as the Cedar Meats outbreak.

Near empty shelves are seen at the vegetable section of a supermarket amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak in Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, in this Aug 2, 2020 photo obtained from social media. (Photo: Klarissa Leahy/via REUTERS)

Melbourne needs to see hundreds of thousands fewer interaction between people every day to bring case numbers down from their current levels.

The new measures are welcome, in epidemiological terms at least, and are likely to reduce the spread of the virus. And despite the new strictures, the underlying message remains the same: staying at home, and limiting your interactions with other people as much as possible, is crucial to slowing transmission.

Even when Melbourne residents need to leave the house for one of the accepted reasons, physical distancing still remains the most effective preventative intervention.

These new restrictions will not work unless they are followed.


Every morning, Melbourne residents wake up and look at the new daily numbers — often with despair. Over the past few weeks, since the start of stage 3 restrictions, new cases have plateaued at around 400 to 500 every day, but are not decreasing.

As Victoria’s Chief Health Officer Brett Sutton pointed out today, stage 3 restrictions have prevented cases spiralling out of control, but have not reduced numbers as much as we would like.

The latest restrictions will apply for six weeks, but there will be a daily review of the data by health authorities. The restrictions could be modified or extended if there are any hiccups along the way.

We expect to see the effects from the latest round of lockdown restrictions to become apparent in roughly two weeks’ time.

LISTEN: Retrenchment: What is fair compensation, clear communication and empathy in letting people go?

BOOKMARK THIS: Our comprehensive coverage of the coronavirus outbreak and its developments

Download our app or subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on the coronavirus outbreak:

Philip Russo is Associate Professor and Director Cabrini Monash University Department of Nursing Research, Monash University. Brett Mitchell is Professor of Nursing at the University of Newcastle. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.

Source: CNA/sl


Also worth reading