Lapses flagged by the A.G.O.
The National Parks Board was criticised for lapses in documentation, obtaining approval and recovering money over the S$1.06 billion Gardens by the Bay project:
- Allowed a consultant to commence services valued at S$2.37 million before approval was obtained to call for a limited tender
- Three consultancy services contracts estimated at S$20.77 million awarded without competition.
- 45 instances where approvals were obtained after contract variation works had been carried out or completed
- No system to monitor and recover money due from its consultants and contractors for procurement of information management services; could not ascertain if S$199,800 it had paid on their behalf had been recovered
Singapore Polytechnic (SP) was taken to task over related-party transactions:
- Did not recover salaries and costs of seconding a senior officer from its subsidiary Singapore Polytechnic International (SPI) and did not impose secondment charges. The cost to SP amounted to about S$1.23 million as of Dec 31, 2014.
- Leased land parcel at below market rate to Singapore Polytechnic Graduates Guild (SPGG), against government policy of letting premises at market rates
Institute of Technical Education (ITE) was criticised over related-party transactions and irregularities in how it awarded and managed contracts:
- Leased office space to subsidiary ITE Education Services (ITEES) without obtaining approval
- Did not charge ITEES market rate, thus undercharging by S$480,000 for the five-year licence period
- Did not ensure correct billing of ITEES for services, resulting in overbilling, underbilling or late billing
- in seven out of 20 invoices checked by the AGO
- Awarded contract to cafeteria operator worth S$635,000, even though the tenderer did not meet an evaluation criterion
- Did not take enforcement action against operator when it did not meet contractual requirements
Temasek Polytechnic
- Invested in five bonds worth S$61.5 million before obtaining approval from its Investment Committee
- Did not impose charges for use of its carparks until June last year, and subsequently charged below market rates for some users, which is against government policy
Workforce Development Agency
- Did not ensure partners adhered to audit requirements for the use of grants. There were also over-disbursements of grants totalling S$170,100 and delays in recovery of unused grants, estimated at S$461,000
- Did not enforce programme requirements. In one case it did not ensure a training partner fulfilled its contractual obligations by making sure the trainees were hired by the companies they apprenticed at. Ten out of 17 trainees were not hired.