Skip to main content




Europe battles surge in COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes

Europe battles surge in COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes

A patient with COVID-19 is helped by a caretaker during a physical therapy session at the Vitalia Canillejas elderly care home in Madrid, Spain, Nov 23, 2020. (Photo: AP/Bernat Armangue)

MADRID: As the two mortuary workers pushed a stretcher with a bagged corpse out of the room, the elderly man in the adjacent bed briefly awakened from his dementia. "Is he dead?" he muttered, extending his arm, trying to touch his roommate for the last time.

Reflecting on a scene repeated too many times, one of the workers, Manel Rivera, despaired at the growing number of elderly people dying as the coronavirus resurges.

"The sad thing is," he said of the surviving man in the Barcelona nursing home, "in a few days we'll probably come back for him."

Mortuary workers are again busy around-the-clock in nursing homes and hospices across Europe, amid outbreaks that this time are causing havoc mostly in facilities spared during the spring.

In the United States, patients in nursing homes and long-term care facilities and those who care for them have accounted for a staggering 39 per cent of the country's 281,000 coronavirus deaths.

The surge in Europe is happening despite the retaining wall of measures erected since the spring, including facilities tailored only for residents with coronavirus.

It is also pitching authorities and elder care professionals into a race against the clock before mass vaccinations can begin.

In response, Portugal has deployed military units to train nursing home staff in disinfection.

In France, where at least 5,000 institutionalised elderly have died in the past month, and in Germany and Italy, where the summer respite has been followed by an upward turn since September, visits by relatives to nursing homes are being restricted again or banned altogether.

Separated by a curtain, a person sleeps in a bed as mortuary workers prepare the body of an elderly person who died of COVID-19 in a nursing home in Barcelona, Spain, Nov 19, 2020. (Photo: AP/Emilio Morenatti) Virus Outbreak Europe Nursing Homes

Most countries are ramping up screening of workers and residents, trying to prevent spread by asymptomatic virus carriers. The strategy has helped Belgium reduce nursing home deaths from 63 per cent of all COVID-19 fatalities before mid-June to 39 per cent at the end of November.

But in Spain, where the pandemic has ignited a polarised debate on the country's ability to care for Europe's fastest-ageing society, nursing home coronavirus deaths have been climbing for two months.

They now make up roughly half of all new daily fatalities, a similar share as in March and April. New daily infections are also disproportionate in the homes - 13 cases inside for every one outside.

There is reason for hope, however, as Britain became the first country in the world to authorise a rigorously tested COVID-19 vaccine last week, and could begin dispensing it within days, prioritising nursing home residents and those who care for them, followed by other elderly and health care workers.

READ: Britain gets ready for roll-out of Pfizer's COVID-19 vaccine this week

Nursing homes are also at or near the top of the list for vaccines in the US, Spain and many other European countries.

"It's a sensible, justified and logical measure" to prioritise nursing homes, said Miguel Vazquez, head of Madrid's Pladigmare association of residents' relatives. After a "shameful" death toll and a record of repeating mistakes, he said, "not doing so would be a deliberate death sentence".

Residents sit in a living room and watch TV at the Icaria nursing home in Barcelona, Spain, Nov 27, 2020. (Photo: AP/Emilio Morenatti) Virus Outbreak Europe Nursing Homes

Some things have improved since the spring. Care workers have learned to make the best use of protective equipment and tests, which are no longer in such short supply.

There is a better grasp of what is going on inside most facilities, and experts have learned how COVID-19 affects the elderly, with symptoms such as diarrhoea and rashes that had been overlooked.

"It really is a chameleon disease that fools us all," said Dr Jose Augusto Garcia Navarro, head of Spain's Society for Geriatrics and Gerontology.

One of the gravest mistakes in the early days was to cloister the elderly in damaging isolation, Garcia Navarro said, leading to loss of mobility, insomnia, malnourishment, depression and other ailments that affected and even killed many.

"It's paramount to guarantee physio, occupational and psychological therapies for the infected," he said. "That didn't happen during the first wave and is not happening as it should during the second one."

Residents take part in a gym session at the Icaria nursing home in Barcelona, Spain, Nov 11, 2020. (Photo: AP/Emilio Morenatti) Virus Outbreak Europe Nursing Homes

An initiative in Spain is trying to remedy that with facilities for recovering virus patients who, while remaining contagious, have nowhere to isolate or keep active. They come from their own homes or from the many small care facilities that have no way to separate residents.

At the Vitalia Canillejas Home in Madrid, Belkis Zoraida Cuevas, 83, is recovering from the virus, which has kept her away from her husband, 92-year-old Joaquin Gonzalez, for the longest period in more than six decades of marriage.

"Oh my God! What a crisis of anxiety. How I've cried," Cuevas said. "I'm doing better now, but this has been too much to handle. It's like going to war without weapons."

As he walked with the help of a therapist to recover lost mobility during a month-long hospitalisation, 87-year-old Pedro Marcelo said: "I'm not afraid of dying, I just want to move a little bit better until the day for me to go arrives."

A study of blood samples in all Madrid nursing homes showed that 53 per cent of the 55,000 residents live in facilities where more than half of residents have developed antibodies.

"It's sad to put it this way," said Paz Membibre, who manages a dozen centres for the Vitalia Home group in or around the Spanish capital, "but the damage we suffered has protected us now." How long immunity might last, however, is a question scientists are still trying to answer.

READ: COVID-19 reinfection casts doubt on virus immunity - Study

READ: UK study finds evidence of waning antibody immunity to COVID-19 over time​​​​​​​

Through a window, Angels Trepat, 59, says goodbye to her mother Angelina, 91, after visiting her at the Icaria nursing home in Barcelona, Spain, Nov 27, 2020. (Photo: AP/Emilio Morenatti) Virus Outbreak Europe Nursing Homes

Meanwhile, across the continent, infections often shoot up to dozens or more than 100 in just a matter of 48 hours.

In Spain, the biggest surges of cases and deaths are now in the southern Andalucia and central Castilla Leon regions that dodged the worst during the spring. In neighbouring France, infections are now more spread out than during the spring, when they concentrated in hot spots.

In Berlin, where 14 people recently died of coronavirus in a nursing home of 90 residents, city officials said strict rules were not being applied.

Garcia Navarro said most of the affected facilities in Spain are trying to control the virus with staff shortages as care workers fall sick. In a few cases, he said, "they are still not complying with safety protocols".

In a scathing report into how thousands were abandoned in nursing homes, many without medical treatment, in Madrid and Barcelona in the spring, Amnesty International said this week that some of the same problems still exist, including health protocols that recommend prioritising the young over the elderly.

Bureaucracy and mismanagement have also played a role. An internal Spanish government analysis seen by the Associated Press lists 30 main errors that led to the deaths of over 20,000 elderly patients with COVID-19 before mid-May. But its recommendations are still being revised with regional officials, and some have not been implemented.

BOOKMARK THIS: Our comprehensive coverage of the coronavirus outbreak and its developments

Download our app or subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on the coronavirus outbreak:

Source: AP/dv


Also worth reading