Commentary: After two years of COVID-19, are our newly formed habits here to stay?
Although the pandemic forced the world to acquire new habits to protect ourselves against the virus, people are now quickly returning to some pre-pandemic ways, says this lecturer.
SWANSEA, Wales: The World Health Organization officially declared COVID-19 a pandemic on Mar 11, 2020. Now, two years later, there’s light for some at the end of the tunnel. In many wealthier countries, which have benefited from several rounds of vaccination, the worst of the pandemic is over.
We’ve got here by learning a lot of “new” health behaviours, like wearing masks and sanitising our hands. Many of us have also developed a variety of social habits to reduce the virus’ spread – such as working from home, shopping online, travelling locally and socialising less.
But as parts of the world emerge from the pandemic, are these new habits here to stay, or do old habits really die hard? Here’s what data can tell us.
WORKING FROM HOME
One of the biggest changes predicted during the pandemic was a long-term shift towards home or hybrid working. However, there are already signs that this transition might not be as obvious or complete as expected.
In the UK, the proportion of people working from home at least some of the time increased from 27 per cent in 2019 to 37 per cent in 2020, before falling to 30 per cent in January 2022. Similarly, in the US, the proportion working from home declined from 35 per cent in May 2020 to 11 per cent in December 2021.
One of the main reasons people are going back to the office is employers’ expectations. Many companies are concerned that more permanent home working might affect employees’ team building, creativity and productivity.
But among employees, there’s a greater appetite for hybrid and flexible working. One recent multi-national survey found that whereas roughly one-third of workers had worked at home at least some of the time before the pandemic, roughly half said that they want to in the future.
The pandemic didn’t create the habit of online shopping, but it made more of us do it. Did this make us realise that we don’t need actual stores anymore?
Shopping in brick-and-mortar stores has already started to recover. Recent data on people’s movements, gathered anonymously from mobile devices, shows how in many countries, before Omicron hit, travel to retail and recreation spaces was back up to pre-pandemic levels and is already starting to rebound after Omicron.
The rise in online sales has also not been as dramatic or sustained as many predicted. In the UK, online sales made up 20 per cent of total retail sales before the pandemic. By February 2021 this had risen to 36 per cent, before declining steadily to 25 per cent in February 2022.
One habit that might take longer to recover is our pre-pandemic love of international travel. It has taken a hit around the world, and the sector is still struggling. The UN’s International Civil Aviation Organization projects that international travel in 2022 will still be down by nearly a half compared to 2019.
One British survey conducted last September found that while 80 per cent of people were planning on holidaying in the UK in the next year, only around 40 per cent were considering going abroad. In comparison, in the 12 months up to July 2019, 64 per cent of Britons travelled abroad for a holiday according to one travel industry body.
People’s reluctance to travel has been largely down to concerns over the virus and confusion over travel rules. As worries decline and rules get lifted, we may see a “mini-boom” in holidaymaking.
Early in the pandemic, some commentators – including the US chief medical adviser Dr Anthony Fauci – suggested that we might never return to shaking hands. I, with my colleague Dr Kimberly Dienes, argued that it was vital these rituals make a comeback, as they have several social, psychological and even biological benefits.
Are social-distancing habits, including meeting fewer people and having less physical contact with those we do, here to stay? For most people, no. Data shows that only one-third of people in the UK are still socially distancing regularly, the lowest proportion since the pandemic began.
But truly, only time will tell how much the pandemic will have changed our habits. However, bolder predictions – that the pandemic was going to completely and irrevocably change our ways of working, shopping, travelling and socialising – now seem premature and exaggerated.
The pandemic has taught us we can work, learn, shop and socialise in different ways, but the question now is whether we still want to.
RETURNING TO PRE-PANDEMIC NORMALCY
Humans have basic needs, such as autonomy, feeling related to others, and feeling effective and competent in what we do. Part of the challenge with home working, for example, is that it simultaneously fulfils one need by giving us greater autonomy but takes away another by making us less connected.
Expanding adequately supported, equality-focused, hybrid and flexible working arrangements is perhaps a promising way to meet both needs.
Some people will have acquired a sense of competence, or at least familiarity, with the new ways of doing things during the pandemic and so may wish to keep doing them.
In some areas – travelling overseas, for example – it may take longer for our competence, and confidence, in old habits to return. However, many seem to be quite quickly returning to old ways and re-learning how to feel competent at doing things that they did before.
The extent to which we’ll go back to our old ways may also depend on our personality traits, which have been shown to shape our compliance with new behaviour. For example, those more open to new experiences by nature, or more extroverted, may be more eager to travel internationally or socialise in larger groups.
Finally, the pandemic may have served as a reminder of how much we appreciate everyday interactions with others, in shops, restaurants and so on. People may be keen to return to familiar ways that revive this – for example, picking something up in a store on the way home from work.
Above all, the pandemic has taught us that we need to connect with others and that there are limits as to how much online communication can replace real, face-to-face interactions.
Simon Nicholas Williams is a Senior Lecturer in People and Organisation at Swansea University. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.