Commentary: Why we probably won't have answers about Omicron variant for weeks
Scientists are scrambling to conduct experiments and study real-world data about the transmissibility and potential to escape vaccines, but that's going to take time, says a researcher.
GOLD COAST, Australia: Researchers around the world are trying to work out whether existing COVID-19 vaccines protect us from the latest variant, Omicron.
The worst-case scenario is the virus has mutated so much in the crucial parts of its genome that it can escape COVID-19 vaccines designed to protect us from earlier versions of the virus – with devastating consequences globally.
But it’s too soon to panic. And vaccines may end up protecting us against Omicron after all, as they have done with earlier variants.
The World Health Organization (WHO) says it will take us another two to four weeks to figure out what’s going on. Here’s what scientists around the world are racing to find out.
The reason Omicron has caused global alarm is due to the number of new mutations throughout the genome of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.
This data, coupled with real world data on the rapid rise in Omicron cases in South Africa, prompted the WHO to designate Omicron a “variant of concern” on Nov 26. Omicron has now been detected in several other countries around the world.
UNDERSTANDING WHAT OMICRON’S NEW MUTATIONS DO
We’ve already seen some Omicron mutations in other variants.
Individually, some of these mutations have been associated with resistance to neutralising antibodies. In other words, these mutations help the virus evade recognition by an immune system primed with a COVID-19 vaccine.
Some of these individual mutations have also been linked with increased transmissibility of the virus from one person to another.
However, Omicron has many unique mutations. For instance, on the spike protein, the protein used in many current vaccines, Omicron has about 30 mutations compared with the virus first detected. Delta has only 10 mutations in its spike protein. So you get an idea of the scale of change.
Investigating the way these multiple mutations interact with one another, rather than individually, will be key to understanding how Omicron behaves compared with other variants.
Looking at these interactions will tell us more about Omicron’s ability to infect cells, cause disease and escape vaccines. And experiments are under way to investigate these mutations and their impacts.
While we wait for the results, we've heard from some of the vaccine manufacturers. Moderna said its vaccine would be less effective against Omicron than against Delta. Meanwhile, Pfizer-BioNTech said its vaccine would still protect against severe disease. Both companies said they could produce tweaked booster vaccines, if needed.
BUT WHY WILL IT TAKE WEEKS TO GET ANSWERS?
Here’s what researchers around the world are working on and why we won’t have answers for a few weeks.
Researchers are taking samples of Omicron from infected people and growing the virus in laboratories. This gives them working stocks of the virus to conduct experiments. This can take time as you’re often starting with tiny amounts of virus from a swab.
This process also relies on access to the right types of cells to grow the virus in and needs to be done in laboratories that offer a high level of biosafety, to contain the virus. Not all researchers have access to these facilities.
Thinking about getting your booster shot? Listen to infectious disease experts weigh in on CNA's Heart of the Matter:
Researchers can also use genetic tools to produce the virus in the laboratory, requiring only the genome sequence of SARS-CoV-2 to begin production. This removes the reliance on patient samples.
They can also produce genetically engineered viruses, called pseudotyped viruses, in the laboratory. These carry only the spike protein. Researchers can also express small portions of the spike protein on the surface of other organisms, such as yeast.
All these options take time to set up, optimise and be used in the types of studies outlined below.
Initial studies will look at how Omicron’s mutations impact the fitness of the variant – its transmissibility and ability to evade vaccine-induced immunity.
For instance, initial experiments will look at Omicron’s ability to infect cells. These studies will tell us how well Omicron’s spike protein interacts with the ACE2 receptor, the gateway to infecting our cells. Further studies will investigate how well Omicron can replicate in cells after gaining entry.
Neutralisation studies will investigate how well antibodies – induced by current vaccines – can neutralise Omicron, or prevent it from infecting cells. Such studies rely on access to serum from vaccinated people and are likely to compare the neutralising capacity of Omicron against other variants.
Studies are also likely to investigate the effect of vaccine booster regimes and earlier infection on how well antibodies neutralise Omicron.
VACCINE PROTECTION IS NOT ALL OR NOTHING
So what can we expect? Until we get the results of these experiments, it’s difficult to say for certain.
Studies of how effective COVID-19 vaccines are against other variants show they are generally less able to induce the type of antibody response we’d like to see, neutralising antibodies. However, when previous variants have emerged, vaccines have continued to protect against severe disease.
Vaccine protection is not all or nothing. We are unlikely to get a perfect neutralising antibody response against Omicron, or no response, rather something in between.
Continued monitoring of real-world data will also be essential to determine how Omicron impacts the broader pandemic.
Whether Omicron is able to spread from seeding events around the world or compete with Delta are questions to be answered in the coming weeks.
Whether infection with Omicron causes less or more serious disease also remains unclear. Monitoring hospitalisation rates will be key.
DON’T FORGET WE’RE STILL DEALING WITH DELTA
Currently fewer than 200 genetic sequences of Omicron have been compiled compared with more than 2.8 million Delta sequences. Delta remains the most dominant variant. So we should continue to use vaccines and therapies we know work against Delta.
It’s also essential we continue with public health measures, such as wearing masks and social distancing, alongside continued vaccination, to combat the spread of SARS-CoV-2 and the emergence of further variants.
Adam Taylor is Early Career Research Leader at the Menzies Health Institute Queensland, Griffith University. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation.