Commentary: Stress makes altruistic people become more selfish
Many say they are more stressed since the COVID-19 pandemic began. Reducing stress could improve altruism, says this researcher.
KINGSTON, Ontario: If you’re feeling stressed right now, you’re not alone. One quarter of Canadians report experiencing high levels of stress on most days and almost half of Canadians say their stress levels have increased since the pandemic began.
And unfortunately, stress affects how we treat the people around us – sadly, it’s often not in a good way. Being stressed can actually make people more egotistical and greedier.
Stress affects us all on multiple levels. It affects our body, mind and behaviours. I was recently part of a team of researchers who examined how stress affects generosity and who is particularly vulnerable to changes in social behaviours when under pressure.
We wanted to understand how stress hormones, brain responses and our thoughts about others work together to explain how stress can make people selfish and why it doesn’t happen to everyone to the same degree.
ALTRUISTIC PEOPLE MORE VULNERABLE TO BECOMING SELFISH UNDER STRESS
In our study, we asked participants to donate to various charities before and after undergoing a social stress. To simulate the consequences of most altruistic acts in the real world, donations in this experiment had real consequences.
Participants were given 20 euros and could keep whatever money they decided not to donate. We found that while keeping the money and being selfish literally paid off, most participants were willing to support charitable causes.
However, after participants were exposed to a social stress, their biological stress responses – as captured in increased levels of the stress hormone cortisol – were negatively linked to their generosity. In other words, higher bodily stress responses diminished altruism.
But not everyone was affected by stress in the same way. Participants’ susceptibility to the stress hormone cortisol was related to their ability to understand others’ inner mental states (like their needs, beliefs, goals or points of view).
This ability is sometimes referred to as mentalising or theory of mind and is positively related to altruistic behaviors. Participants with high mentalising skills were the ones who were particularly vulnerable to becoming more selfish under stress.
STRESS HORMONE AFFECTS OUR BRAINS
We measured participants’ brain activity during charitable giving, both before and after stress, using functional magnetic resonance imaging.
We found that there is a region of the brain that mediates a cortisol-related shift of altruism: The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. This area has long been known to play a key role in altruistic decision-making and cognitive control.The stress hormone cortisol altered the activation patterns in this brain region and mediated the negative effects of stress on altruistic behaviour. It provided the missing link between bodily stress responses and observed changes in our social behaviour. Specifically, it explained how exactly the brain responds to stress and contributes to the changed willingness to help under pressure.
Our study’s findings are important because they reveal several things: First, they help understand the link between the body’s stress responses and the change in our willingness to help others. Societies depend on people’s willingness to share, cooperate and help. Altruism is a building block of functioning societies – high levels of stress reported by many Canadians represent a potential risk factor.
Understanding how stress can impact our prosocial behaviours towards other people and organisations is vital. Understanding this can ultimately help develop new interventions that target the elements altered by stress experience.
Second, not all people are the same: Not everyone shows the same response under stress. Identifying the characteristics that explain susceptibility to stress effects is useful because they can help protect vulnerable people by informing us who they are.
Third, these findings point towards strategies to buffer against the potentially harmful ways we treat others due to stress responses. Specifically, the results suggest that targeted interventions that reduce stress levels may improve altruism (especially in those who are high mentalisers).
More research is needed to prove this proposition, but it provides an exciting avenue for anyone interested in creating more prosocial communities and environments. While it might not be the first thing that comes to mind, new and effective ways to reduce stress in vulnerable members of our communities could be key to ensure supportive social environments.
Anita Tusche is an assistant professor of psychology at Queen’s University, Ontario. The commentary first appeared on The Conversation.