Commentary: Could you have had COVID-19 and not realised it?
Knowing whether we have caught the virus before is of little practical benefit, so antibody testing for past infections should be reserved for special medical or public health needs, says this academic.
CANBERRA: It seems like not a day goes by without learning that someone in our inner circle of family, friends and colleagues has COVID-19. When we ask how unwell our acquaintance is, the responses vary from “they’re really ill” to “you wouldn’t even know they had it”.
This is in line with studies that report moderate to severe illness in a minority of people (usually older with other risk factors) and that up to one in three positive people exhibits no symptoms.
Given the ubiquitous presence of this highly infectious coronavirus in our community and the high rate of asymptomatic illness, those who have not been diagnosed with COVID-19 might wonder: “How would I know if I had been infected?” and “Does it matter if I have?”
HOW IS COVID-19 DIAGNOSED?
Most people know they’ve had COVID-19 because they had a fever or upper respiratory tract symptoms and/or were exposed to an infected person and had a swab test (PCR or rapid antigen) that detected the COVID-19 virus (SARS-CoV-2) in the upper airway. People with consistent symptoms or high-risk exposures who were not able to access PCR tests or ART to confirm their diagnosis could have instead presumed themselves positive and quarantined.
It is possible to diagnose past infections in those who never tested positive. A blood test can look for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies (also known as immunoglobulins).
When we are infected with SARS-CoV-2, our immune system launches a precision counter strike by producing antibodies against viral targets, specifically the Spike (S) and Nucleocapsid (N) proteins. COVID-19 vaccines induce a similar immune response against the S protein only. The S antibody “neutralises” the invader by preventing the virus from attaching to human cells.
These antibodies can be detected within one to three weeks after infection and persist for at least six months – potentially much longer. A blood test that shows antibodies to S and N proteins indicates that someone had been previously infected. Detection of antibodies to the S protein only indicates vaccination (but not infection).
THE PROBLEM WITH ANTIBODY TESTS
Before you rush off to get a COVID-19 antibody test, there are a few notes of caution. There is still much to learn about the characteristics of the immune response to COVID-19 infection.
Not everyone mounts a detectable antibody response following infection and levels can decline to undetectable levels after several months in some people.
Because there are other circulating seasonal coronaviruses (such as those that cause the common cold), tests may also pick up antibodies to non-SARS-CoV-2 strains, leading to “false positive” results.
Commercial and public hospital pathology labs can perform SARS-CoV-2 antibody testing, but the interpretation of results should be undertaken carefully.
So, antibody testing should really only be done when there’s a good reason to, say, when confirming past infection or if knowing the effectiveness of vaccination is important for the current care of an individual, like diagnosing a post-infection complication or eligibility for a specific treatment.
It could also be useful for contact tracing or for assessing the background population rate of infection.
IS IT POSSIBLE TO TEST ANTIBODIES FOR THE POPULATION?
“Seroprevalence studies” test for the presence of SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in repositories of stored blood that are representative of the general population, such as from a blood bank. This data helps to understand the true extent of COVID-19 infections and vaccination status in the community (and informs our assessment of population susceptibility to future infection and reinfection).
It’s more useful than daily reported case numbers, which are skewed towards symptomatic individuals and those with access to swab testing.
New research from the World Health Organization, which has yet to be reviewed by other scientists, reported the results of a meta-analysis of over 800 seroprevalence studies performed around the world since 2020.
They estimated that by July 2021, 45.2 per cent of the global population had SARS-CoV-2 antibodies due to past infection or vaccination, eight times the estimate (5.5 per cent) from a year earlier.
There are plans to conduct fresh seroprevalence studies in Australia in the coming year, which will update local data and help us understand to what extent the Omicron wave has washed through the population.
DOES IT MATTER IF I HAD COVID-19 AND DIDN’T KNOW?
For most people, knowing your COVID-19 infection status is unlikely to be more than a topic of dinnertime conversation. While some studies have pointed to a less robust and durable antibody response following mild or asymptomatic infection compared with severe illness, it is not known how this influences protection from reinfection.
Certainly, the knowledge we have antibodies from past infections should not deter us from being fully up-to-date with COVID-19 vaccination, which remains the best protection against severe illness.
There are reports of people with mild or asymptomatic COVID-19 infection developing long COVID-19 – persistent or relapsing symptoms that last several months after initial infection.
Symptoms can include shortness of breath, physical and mental fatigue, exercise intolerance, headaches and muscle and joint pain. However, the likelihood of developing this condition appears higher in those who suffer a heavier initial bout of COVID-19 illness. This might be linked to a higher viral load at that time.
As we enter the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic and given that up to one in three infections may be asymptomatic, it is likely that many of us have been infected without knowing it.
If you are experiencing lingering fatigue, brain fog or other symptoms that could be long COVID-19, you should talk to your GP. Otherwise, knowing our COVID-19 infection status is unlikely to be of much practical benefit. Antibody testing should be reserved for specific medical or public health indications.
Being up-to-date with COVID-19 vaccinations is still our best defence against severe illness moving forward.
Ashwin Swaminathan is a Senior Lecturer at the Australian National University. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.