Skip to main content
Best News Website or Mobile Service
WAN-IFRA Digital Media Awards Worldwide 2022
Best News Website or Mobile Service
Digital Media Awards Worldwide 2022
Hamburger Menu
Advertisement
Advertisement

Singapore

Potential Grab, Trans-cab merger could block entry and expansion of rival ride-hailing platforms: Competition watchdog

The Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore has raised concerns over how Trans-cab drivers may use other platforms, should Grab succeed in its proposed takeover of the taxi operator.

Potential Grab, Trans-cab merger could block entry and expansion of rival ride-hailing platforms: Competition watchdog

Grab had announced plans to acquire Singapore's third-largest taxi operator Trans-cab in 2023. (File photo: TODAY)

SINGAPORE: Tech firm Grab's proposed takeover of Trans-cab could affect how drivers employed by the taxi operator use other ride-hailing platforms, Singapore's competition watchdog said on Monday (Oct 16).

The Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS) added that this may in turn "raise barriers to expansion and entry" for rival platforms, given the importance of scale in the industry. 

These concerns, which were flagged as part of feedback from industry figures, are notwithstanding the fact that under Singapore's point-to-point transport regulatory framework, licensed ride-hail operators are not allowed to impose exclusive arrangements preventing their drivers from using other platforms.

If the merger - first announced in July - goes through, Grab's private-hire car rental arm Grab Rentals will acquire 100 per cent of shares in Trans-cab, Singapore's third-largest taxi operator with a fleet of more than 2,500 vehicles.

Both parties expect the deal to close in the fourth quarter of 2023, subject to regulatory approvals and other customary closing conditions.

CCCS - a statutory board under the Ministry of Trade and Industry - had sought public feedback in August on how the move could affect the price, quality and quantity of street- and ride-hailing services by taxi and private-hire car drivers, among other aspects.

Grab and Trans-cab have argued that the acquisition will not result in a substantial lessening of competition, citing "minimal overlaps" between them; a lack of prohibitive barriers to entry; and a highly fragmented and competitive rental market.

On Monday, CCCS said in a media release that upon completion of an initial review, it was "unable to conclude" that the proposed acquisition would not give rise to any competition concerns.

It has since flagged raised these concerns with Grab and Trans-cab, and will "review the competition effects of the proposed acquisition in greater detail".

At this juncture, the two parties may offer what CCCS called "commitments", to address the potential competition concerns around their merger. These refer to measures to remedy, mitigate or prevent the substantial lessening of competition or any adverse effect arising from the deal.

Otherwise, the watchdog will proceed to a more in-depth review of the proposed acquisition.

In response, Grab said on Monday that its priority is to work closely with CCCS to address areas that require further review.

It added that Grab and Trans-cab are committed to ensuring that the acquisition "benefits commuters and helps raise the overall standards of the point-to-point transportation industry".

"Digitalising Trans-cab’s fleet will improve driver productivity and taxi availability so that consumers can get a ride more easily."

This will also improve driver earnings, said Grab.

Grab added in its response that it intends to abide by LTA’s P2P regulatory framework, which promotes open competition and prohibits any form of anti-competitive behaviours like offering exclusive arrangements to drivers.

"This means that Trans-cab drivers will continue to have the flexibility to earn through multiple ride-hailing platforms and pick up street hail rides," said the company.

Grab's planned acquisition of Trans-cab follows the merger of Strides Taxi and Premier Taxis in May to form Singapore's second-largest taxi operator.

In 2018, CCCS fined Grab and ride-hailing platform Uber S$13 million over their merger. The deal led to a substantial lessening of competition in the market, the watchdog said then, highlighting Grab’s increased prices and changes to its loyalty programme after it bought over Uber's Southeast Asia operations.

Source: CNA/jo(ac)
Advertisement

Also worth reading

Advertisement