Commentary: Setting Netflix's Stranger Things in a 1980s mental health hospital has its dark side
Season four of Stranger Things introduces viewers to Pennhurst Mental Hospital. When the real Pennhurst and other asylums around the world become tourist attractions, we forget these institutions held real people and their stories, says a professor.
In season four, series creators the Duffer Brothers introduce viewers to Pennhurst Mental Hospital for the criminally insane (which is also mentioned in season one).
Viewers follow teenage sleuths Robin and Nancy into Pennhurst, where they are granted permission to speak to Victor Creel, imprisoned because he is thought to have brutally murdered his family.
Although the Pennhurst Mental Hospital portrayed in Stranger Things is fictitious, the location was inspired by the Eastern Pennsylvania State Institution for the Feeble-Minded and Epileptic. Later named the Pennhurst State School and Hospital and located in the woods of Chester County, Pennsylvania, it was founded in 1908 and shut down in 1987.
More than 10,000 people with intellectual disabilities and mental illnesses lived at Pennhurst, many spending their entire lives within its walls.
The real Pennhurst has become a tourist attraction, like dozens of empty asylums around the world, including some in Australia. But as we seek out thrills, we shouldn’t forget these institutions held real people and their stories.
COMMERCIALISING MENTAL INSTITUTIONS INTO TOURIST ATTRACTIONS
Pennhurst was a place of segregation, power, abuse, neglect and torture, fuelled by society’s perception that people with intellectual disabilities were a dangerous threat to social order.
At the dawn of the 19th century’s eugenics movement, people with intellectual disabilities existed on the lowest rung of the human hierarchy. Ultimately, they were removed from the human gene pool through institutionalisation and sterilisation.
In 1987, in response to the disability rights movement’s loud call for de-institutionalisation and after groundbreaking litigation brought by a resident and her family, the State of Pennsylvania closed Pennhurst’s doors.
The courts agreed those in state care had a constitutional right to appropriate treatment and education. More than 1,000 Pennhurst residents began lives of worth and value in the community.
In 2010, the state of Pennsylvania sold the site. Today, Pennhurst exists as a “dark tourism” destination. Pennhurst Asylum entertains visitors with “jump scares” around a narrative of depraved criminality, that simultaneously erases and evokes the inhumane treatment of the people who called Pennhurst home.
To those who lived there and their supporters, Pennhurst is more than the horrors of its past and the commercialisation of its future.
For Dennis Downey and James Conroy, editors of Pennhurst and the Struggle for Disability Rights, Pennhurst represents “one of the great, if unrecognised, freedom struggles of the twentieth century”, fanning the flames of the global de-institutionalisation and independent living movements.
Following Pennhurst’s closure, most Western nations began closing institutions. This independent living movement was a precursor to the 2006 United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability.
Article 19 of the convention obliges signatory nations to ensure “the equal right of all persons with disabilities to live in the community, with choices equal to others”.
And Article 12 asks signatory nations to recognise that all citizens, regardless of disability, have “legal personhood” and therefore should enjoy autonomy and respect.
The convention charges signatory nations with an unequivocal obligation to firmly make the traumatic experiences of institutionalisation a thing of the past, while acknowledging and preserving the stories of trauma as narratives of dignity and respect.
A GLOBAL DARK TOURISM TRADE
Pennhurst is one of many “haunted” tourist attractions worldwide inspired by traumatised lives of people with disability.
A hemisphere away, high on a hill, overlooking the rural town of Ararat in Western Victoria, Australia, stands Aradale Lunatic Asylum, the location of the notorious J-Ward.
During its years of operation from 1867 to 1993, it was home to more than 10,000 people with disabilities.
Like Pennhurst, the past two decades have seen a transformation of Aradale into a tourist attraction, exploiting the very real and horrific life experiences of the people who called it home.
Thrill-seekers can join the Aradale ghost tour and be haunted by such ghostly “tickling, strange smells, banging sounds, shadows and other spooky sensations”.
Tours and “paranormal investigations” also operate at the former Mayday Hills Lunatic Asylum, in Beechworth, Victoria. Tours of Sydney’s Gladesville Mental Hospital, formerly Tarban Creek Lunatic Asylum, are currently on hold due to COVID-19.
Shuttered institutions that were once home to people with disabilities in the United States, Norway, Austria and South Korea are regularly grouped into terrifying online itineraries.
ACKNOWLEDGE AND PRESERVE STORIES OF TRAUMA
Dark tourism operators sell thrilling customer experiences – but the stories of people with disabilities who lived behind the walls of institutions like Pennhurst and Aradale are much darker.
Forensic psychiatrist Jaydip Sarkar talks about coming face-to-face with killers, rapists and other offenders, and why he chose this high-stakes career on CNA's Heavy Duty:
By relying on offensive and misguided portrayals of people with disability as horrifying, dangerous and criminal, operators exploit the ways residents were treated for commercialised entertainment.
Ironically, London’s Bethlem Hospital (from which the word “bedlam” originated) reportedly ran tours for curious visitors to gawk at residents until 1770. But today, the Bethlem Museum of the Mind houses archives and art “to support the history of mental healthcare and treatment”.
An upcoming exhibition explores how “experiences of trauma, mental distress, contact with mental health services and everyday life can shape and disrupt a person’s sense of home”.
Netflix and filmmakers like the Duffer Brothers have an opportunity to acknowledge and preserve the stories of institutionalised communal trauma.
A simple dedication to Pennhurst residents could even be added to a Stranger Things episode or opening credits. It could educate a generation of world citizens about the crimes of the past and the intrinsic personhood of all of humanity.
Joanne Watson is a Senior Lecturer in Disability and Inclusion at Deakin University. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.